Chapter XIII.—The first order of
production maintained by the heretics is altogether indefensible.
1.
I now proceed to show, as follows,
that the first order of production, as conceived of by them, must be
rejected. For they maintain that Nous and Aletheia were produced from
Bythus and his Ennœa, which is proved to be a contradiction. For Nous is
that which is itself chief, and highest, and, as it were, the principle
and source of all understanding. Ennœa, again, which arises from him, is
any sort of emotion concerning any subject. It cannot be, therefore, that
Nous was produced by Bythus and Ennœa; it would be more like the truth
for them to maintain that Ennœa was produced as the daughter of the
Propator and this Nous. For Ennœa is not the daughter of Nous, as they
assert, but Nous becomes the father of Ennœa. For how can Nous have been
produced by the Propator, when he holds the chief and primary place of
that hidden and invisible affection which is within Him? By this
affection sense is produced, and Ennœa, and Enthymesis, and other things
which are simply synonyms for Nous himself. As I have said already, they
are merely certain definite exercises in thought of that very power
concerning some particular subject. We understand the [several] terms
according to their
3043
length and breadth of meaning, not according to any [fundamental] change
[of signification]; and the [various exercises of thought] are limited by
[the same sphere of] knowledge, and are expressed together by [the same]
term, the [very same] sense remaining within, and creating, and
administering, and freely governing even by its own power, and as it
pleases, the things which have been previously mentioned.
2. For the first exercise of that [power] respecting
anything, is styled Ennœa; but when it continues, and gathers strength,
and takes possession of the whole soul, it is called Enthymesis. This
Enthymesis, again, when it exercises itself a long time on the same
point, and has, as it were, been proved, is named Sensation. And this
Sensation, when it is much developed, becomes Counsel. The increase,
again, and greatly developed exercise of this Counsel becomes the
Examination of thought (Judgment); and this remaining in the mind is most
properly termed Logos (reason), from which the spoken Logos (word)
proceeds.
3044
But all the [exercises of thought] which have been mentioned are
[fundamentally] one and the same, receiving their origin from Nous, and
obtaining [different] appellation according to their increase. Just as
the human body, which is at one time young, then in the prime of life,
and then old, has received [different] appellations according to its
increase and continuance, but not according to any change of substance,
or on account of any [real] loss of body, so is it with those [mental
exercises]. For, when one [mentally] contemplates anything, he also
thinks of it; and when he thinks of it, he has also knowledge regarding
it; and when he knows it, he also considers it; and when he considers it,
he also mentally handles it; and when he mentally handles it, he also
speaks of it. But, as I have already said, it is Nous who governs all
these [mental processes], while He is himself invisible, and utters
speech of himself by means of those processes which have been mentioned,
as it were by rays [proceeding from Him], but He himself is not sent
forth by any other.
3. These things may properly be said to hold good in
men, since they are compound by nature, and consist of a body and a soul.
But those who affirm that Ennœa was sent forth from God, and Nous from
Ennœa, and then, in succession, Logos from these, are, in the first
place, to be blamed as having improperly used these productions; and, in
the next place, as describing the affections, and passions, and mental
tendencies of men, while they [thus prove themselves]
ignorant of God. By their manner of speaking, they ascribe those
things which apply to men to the Father of all, whom they also declare to
be unknown to all; and they deny that He himself made the world, to guard
against attributing want of power
3045
to Him; while, at the same time, they endow Him
with human affections and passions. But if they had known the Scriptures,
and been taught by the truth, they would have known, beyond doubt, that
God is not as men are; and that His thoughts are not like the thoughts of
men.
3046
For the Father of all is at a vast distance
from those affections and passions which operate among men. He is a
simple, uncompounded Being, without diverse members,
3047
and
altogether like, and equal to himself, since He is wholly understanding,
and wholly spirit, and wholly thought, and wholly intelligence, and
wholly reason, and wholly hearing, and wholly seeing, and wholly light,
and the whole source of all that is good—even as the religious
and pious are wont to speak concerning God.
4. He is, however, above [all] these properties, and
therefore indescribable. For He may well and properly be called an
Understanding which comprehends all things, but He is not [on that
account] like the understanding of men; and He may most properly be
termed Light, but He is nothing like that light with which we are
acquainted. And so, in all other particulars, the Father of all is in no
degree similar to human weakness. He is spoken of in these terms
according to the love [we bear Him]; but in point of greatness, our
thoughts regarding Him transcend these expressions. If then, even in the
case of human beings, understanding itself does not arise from emission,
nor is that intelligence which produces other things separated from the
living man, while its motions and affections come into manifestation,
much more will the mind of God, who is all understanding, never by any
means be separated from Himself; nor can anything
3048
[in His
case] be produced as if by a different Being.
5. For if He produced intelligence, then He who did
thus produce intelligence must be understood, in accordance with their
views, as a compound and corporeal Being; so that God, who sent forth
[the intelligence referred to], is separate from it, and the intelligence
which was sent forth separate [from Him]. But if they affirm that
intelligence was sent forth from intelligence, they then cut asunder the
intelligence of God, and divide it into parts. And whither has it gone?
Whence was it sent forth? For whatever is sent forth from any place,
passes of necessity into some other. But what existence was there more
ancient than the intelligence of God, into which they maintain it was
sent forth? And what a vast region that must have been which was capable
of receiving and containing the intelligence of God! If, however, they
affirm [that this emission took place] just as a ray proceeds from the
sun, then, as the subjacent air which receives the ray must have had an
existence prior to it, so [by such reasoning] they will indicate that
there was something in existence, into which the intelligence of God was
sent forth, capable of containing it, and more ancient than itself.
Following upon this, we must hold that, as we see the sun, which is less
than all things, sending forth rays from himself to a great distance, so
likewise we say that the Propator sent forth a ray beyond, and to a great
distance from, Himself. But what can be conceived of beyond, or at a
distance from, God, into which He sent forth this ray?
6. If, again, they affirm that that [intelligence] was
not sent forth beyond the Father, but within the Father Himself, then, in
the first place, it becomes superfluous to say that it was sent forth at
all. For how could it have been sent forth if it continued within the
Father? For an emission is the manifestation of that which is emitted,
beyond him who emits it. In the next place, this [intelligence] being
sent forth, both that Logos who springs from Him will still be within the
Father, as will also be the future emissions proceeding from Logos.
These, then, cannot in such a case be ignorant of the Father, since they
are within Him; nor, being all equally surrounded by the Father, can any
one know Him less [than another] according to the descending order of
their emission. And all of them must also in an equal measure continue
impassible, since they exist in the bosom of their Father, and none of
them can ever sink into a state of degeneracy or degradation. For with
the Father there is no degeneracy, unless perchance as in a great circle
a smaller is contained, and within this one again a smaller; or unless
they affirm of the Father, that, after the manner of a sphere or a
square, He contains within Himself on all sides the likeness of a sphere,
or the production of the rest of the Æons in the form of a square, each
one of these being surrounded by that one who is above him in greatness,
and surrounding in turn that one who is after him in smallness; and that
on this account, the smallest and the last of all, having its place in
the centre, and thus being far separated from the Father, was really
ignorant of the Propator. But if they maintain any such hypothesis, they
must shut up their Bythus within
a definite form and space,
while He both surrounds others, and is surrounded by them; for they must
of necessity acknowledge that there is something outside of Him which
surrounds Him. And none the less will the talk concerning those that
contain, and those that are contained, flow on into infinitude; and all
[the Æons] will most clearly appear to be bodies enclosed [by one
another].
7. Further, they must also confess either that He is
mere vacuity, or that the entire universe is within Him; and in that case
all will in like degree partake of the Father. Just as, if one forms
circles in water, or round or square figures, all these will equally
partake of water; just as those, again, which are framed in the air, must
necessarily partake of air, and those which [are formed] in light, of
light; so must those also who are within Him all equally partake of the
Father, ignorance having no place among them. Where, then, is this
partaking of the Father who fills [all things]? If, indeed, He has filled
[all things], there will be no ignorance among them. On this ground,
then, their work of [supposed] degeneracy is brought to nothing, and the
production of matter with the formation of the rest of the world; which
things they maintain to have derived their substance from passion and
ignorance. If, on the other hand, they acknowledge that He is vacuity,
then they fall into the greatest blasphemy; they deny His spiritual
nature. For how can He be a spiritual being, who cannot fill even those
things which are within Him?
8. Now, these remarks which have been made concerning
the emission of intelligence are in like manner applicable in opposition
to those who belong to the school of Basilides, as well as in opposition
to the rest of the Gnostics, from whom these also (the Valentinians) have
adopted the ideas about emissions, and were refuted in the first book.
But I have now plainly shown that the first production of Nous, that is,
of the intelligence they speak of, is an untenable and impossible
opinion. And let us see how the matter stands with respect to the rest
[of the Æons]. For they maintain that Logos and Zoe were sent forth by
him (i.e., Nous) as fashioners of this Pleroma; while they conceive of an
emission of Logos, that is, the Word after the analogy of human feelings,
and rashly form conjectures respecting God, as if they had discovered
something wonderful in their assertion that Logos was I produced by Nous.
All indeed have a clear perception that this may be logically affirmed
with respect to men.
3049
But in Him who is God over all, since
He is all Nous, and all Logos, as I have said before, and has in Himself
nothing more ancient or late than another, and nothing at variance with
another, but continues altogether equal, and similar, and homogeneous,
there is no longer ground for conceiving of such production in the order
which has been mentioned. Just as he does not err who declares that God
is all vision, and all hearing (for in what manner He sees, in that also
He hears; and in what manner He hears, in that also He sees), so also he
who affirms that He is all intelligence, and all word, and that, in
whatever respect He is intelligence, in that also He is word, and that
this Nous is His Logos, will still indeed have only an inadequate
conception of the Father of all, but will entertain far more becoming
[thoughts regarding Him] than do those who transfer the generation of the
word to which men gave utterance to the eternal Word of God, assigning a
beginning and course of production [to Him], even as they do to their own
word. And in what respect will the Word of God—yea, rather God
Himself, since He is the Word—differ from the word of men, if He
follows the same order and process of generation?
9. They have fallen into error, too, respecting Zoe, by
maintaining that she was produced in the sixth place, when it behoved her
to take precedence of all [the rest], since God is life, and
incorruption, and truth. And these and such like attributes have not been
produced according to a gradual scale of descent, but they are names of
those perfections which always exist in God, so far as it is possible and
proper for men to hear and to speak of God. For with the name of God the
following words will harmonize: intelligence, word, life, incorruption,
truth, wisdom, goodness, and such like. And neither can any one maintain
that intelligence is more ancient than life, for intelligence itself is
life; nor that life is later than intelligence, so that He who is the
intellect of all, that is God, should at one time have been destitute of
life. But if they affirm that life was indeed [previously] in the Father,
but was produced in the sixth place in order that the Word might live,
surely it ought long before, [according to such reasoning,] to have been
sent forth, in the fourth place, that Nous might have life; and still
further, even before Him, [it should have been] with Bythus, that their
Bythus might live. For to reckon Sige, indeed, along with their Propator,
and to assign her to Him as His consort, while they do not join Zoe to
the number,—is not this to surpass all other madness?
10. Again, as to the second production which proceeds
from these [Æons who have been mentioned],—that, namely, of Homo
and Ecclesia,—their very fathers, falsely styled Gnostics, strive
among themselves, each one seeking to make good his own opinions, and
thus convicting themselves of being wicked thieves.
They
maintain that it is more suitable to [the theory of] production—
as being, in fact, truth-like—that the Word was produced by man,
and not man by the Word; and that man existed prior to the Word, and that
this is really He who is God over all. And thus it is, as I have
previously remarked, that heaping together with a kind of plausibility
all human feelings, and mental exercises, and formation of intentions,
and utterances of words, they have lied with no plausibility at all
against God. For while they ascribe the things which happen to men, and
whatsoever they recognise themselves as experiencing, to the divine
reason, they seem to those who are ignorant of God to make statements
suitable enough. And by these human passions, drawing away their
intelligence, while they describe the origin and production of the Word
of God in the fifth place, they assert that thus they teach wonderful
mysteries, unspeakable and sublime, known to no one but themselves. It
was, [they affirm,] concerning these that the Lord said, “Seek, and
ye shall find,”
3050
that is, that they should
inquire how Nous and Aletheia proceeded from Bythus and Sage; whether
Logos and Zoe again derive their origin from these and then, whether
Anthropos and Ecclesia proceed from Logos and Zoe.
3043
This
sentence appears to us, after long study, totally untranslateable. The
general meaning seems to be, that whatever name is given to mental acts,
whether they are called
Ennœa
,
Enthymesis
, or by whatever
other appellation, they are all but exercises of the same fundamental
power, styled
Nous
. Compare the following section.
3044
“The
following,” says Harvey, “may be considered to be consecutive
steps in the evolution of
λόγος
as a
psychological entity. Ennœa,
conception
; Enthymesis,
intention
; Sensation,
thought
; Consilium,
reasoning
;
Cogitationis Examinatio,
judgment
; in Mente Perseverans,
Λόγος ἐνδιάθετος
;
Emissibile Verbum,
Λόγος προφοικός
.”
3045
That is, lest He should be thought destitute of power,
as having been unable to prevent evil from having a place in
creation.
3046
Isa. lv.
8
.
3047
The Latin expression is
“similimembrius,” which some regard as the translation of
ὁμοιόκωλος
, and others
of
ὁμοιομερής
; but in
either case the meaning will be as given above.
3048
That is, His Nous, Ennœa, etc., can have
no independent existence. The text fluctuates between
“emittitur” and “emittetur.”
3049
That
is, in human beings no doubt,
thought
(Nous) precedes
speech
(Logos).
3050
Matt. vii. 7
.