Persons equally; the idea of the Son is inevitably suggested by that word. When was it, then,
that the Son was not? In what category shall we detect His non-existence? In place? There
is none. In time? Our Lord was before all times; and if so, when was He not? And if He was
in the Father, in what place was He not? Tell us that, ye who are so practised in seeing things
out of sight. What kind of interval have your cogitations given a shape to? What vacancy
in the Son, be it of substance or of conception, have you been able to think of, which shows
the Father’s life, when drawn out in parallel, as surpassing that of the Only-begotten? Why,
even of men we cannot say absolutely that any one was not, and then was born. Levi, many
generations before his own birth in the flesh, was tithed by Melchisedech; so the Apostle
says, “Levi also, who receiveth tithes, payed tithes (in Abraham),”212 adding the proof, “for
he was yet in the loins of his father, when” Abraham met the priest of the Most High. If,
then, a man in a certain sense is not, and is then born, having existed beforehand by virtue
of kinship of substance in his progenitor, according to an Apostle’s testimony, how as to
the Divine life do they dare to utter the thought that He was not, and then was begotten?
For He ‘is in the Father,’ as our Lord has told us; “I am in the Father, and the Father in
Me213,” each of course being in the other in two different senses; the Son being in the
Father as the beauty of the image is to be found in the form from which it has been outlined;
and the Father in the Son, as that original beauty is to be found in the image of itself. Now
in all hand-made images the interval of time is a point of separation between the model and
that to which it lends its form; but there the one cannot be separated from the other, neither
the “express image” from the “Person,” to use the Apostle’s words214, nor the “brightness”
from the “glory” of God, nor the representation from the goodness; but when once thought
has grasped one of these, it has admitted the associated Verity as well. “Being,” he says (not
becoming), “the brightness of His glory215;” so that clearly we may rid ourselves for ever of
the blasphemy which lurks in either of those two conceptions; viz., that the Only-begotten
can be thought of as Ungenerate (for he says “the brightness of His glory,” the brightness
coming from the glory, and not, reversely, the glory from the brightness); or that He ever
began to be. For the word “being” is a witness that interprets to us the Son’s continuity and
eternity and superiority to all marks of time.
What occasion, then, had our foes for proposing for the damage of our Faith that trifling
question, which they think unanswerable and, so, a proving of their own doctrine, and which
they are continually asking, namely, ‘whether One who is can be generated.’ We may boldly
answer them at once, that He who is in the Ungenerate was generated from Him, and does
212 Heb. vii. 9, 10; Genesis xiv. 18.
213 John x. 38.
214 Heb. i.
215 Heb. i. 3. (ὢν, not γενόμενος).
179
Answer to the question he is always asking, “Can He who is be begotten?