Chapter IV.—Of the
Argument Drawn from
1 Cor. XI.
5–16
.
But in so far as it is the custom to argue even
from the Scriptures in opposition to truth, there is immediately urged
against us the fact that “no mention of virgins is made by the
apostle where he is prescribing about the veil, but that
‘women’ only are named; whereas, if he had willed virgins
as well to be covered, he would have pronounced concerning
‘virgins’ also together with the ‘women’ named;
just as,” says (our opponent), “in that passage where he is
treating of marriage,
290
he declares likewise
with regard to ‘virgins’ what observance is to be
followed.” And accordingly (it is urged) that “they
are not comprised in the law of veiling the head, as not being named in
this law; nay rather, that this is the origin of their being
un
veiled, inasmuch as they who are not
named
are not
bidden
.”
But we withal retort the self-same line of
argument. For he who knew elsewhere how to make mention of each
sex—of
virgin
I mean, and
woman
, that is,
not-virgin
—for distinction’s sake; in these
(passages), in which he does
not
name a
virgin
, points
out (by not making the distinction) community of condition.
Otherwise he could here also have marked the difference between
virgin
and
woman
, just as elsewhere he says,
“Divided is the
woman
and the
virgin
.”
291
Therefore those
whom, by passing them over in silence, he has not divided, he has
included in the other species.
Nor yet, because in that case “divided is
both
woman
and
virgin
,” will this division exert
its patronizing influence in the present case as well, as some will
have it. For how many sayings, uttered on another occasion, have
no weight—in cases, to wit, where they are
not
uttered—unless the subject-matter be the same as on the other
occasion, so that the one utterance may suffice! But the former
case of
virgin
and
woman
is widely “divided”
from the present question. “Divided,” he says,
“is the
woman
and the
virgin
.”
Why? Inasmuch as “the unmarried,” that is, the
virgin
, “is anxious about those (things) which are the
Lord’s, that she may be holy both in body and in spirit; but the
married,” that is, the
not-virgin
, “is anxious how
she may please her husband.” This will be the
interpretation of that “division,” having no place in this
passage (now under consideration); in which pronouncement is made
neither about marriage, nor about the mind and the thought of
woman
and of
virgin
, but about the veiling of the
head. Of which (veiling) the Holy Spirit, willing that there
should be no distinction, willed that by the one name of
woman
should likewise be understood the
virgin
; whom, by not specially
naming, He has not separated from the
woman
, and, by not
separating, has conjoined to her from whom He has not separated
her.
Is it now, then, a “novelty” to use
the primary word, and nevertheless to have the other (subordinate
divisions) understood in that word, in cases where there is no
necessity for individually distinguishing the (various parts of the)
universal whole? Naturally, a compendious style of speech is both
pleasing and necessary; inasmuch as diffuse speech is both tiresome and
vain. So, too, we are content with general words, which
comprehend in themselves the understanding of the specialties.
Proceed we, then, to the word itself. The word (expressing the)
natural
(distinction) is
female
. Of the natural
word, the
general
word is
woman
. Of the
general
, again, the
special
is
virgin
, or
wife
, or
widow
, or whatever other names, even of
the
successive stages
of life, are added hereto. Subject, therefore, the
special
is to the
general
(because the general is prior); and the
succedent
to the
antecedent
, and the
partial
to
the
universal
: (each) is implied in the word itself to
which it is subject; and is signified in it, because contained in
it. Thus neither
hand
, nor
foot
, nor any one of the
members
, requires to be signified when the
body
is
named. And if you say the
universe
, therein will be both
the heaven and the things that are in it,—sun and moon, and
constellations and stars,—and the earth and the seas, and
everything that goes to make up the list of elements. You will
have named all, when you have named that which is made up of all.
So, too, by naming
woman
, he has named whatever is
woman’s.
290
1 Cor. vii
.
291
1 Cor. vii. 34
.