68
with such a connexion. If there be no connexion between those events, wherein virtue and
vice consist, and any thing antecedent; then, there is no connexion between these events
and any Means or Endeavours used in order to them: and if so, then those means must be
in vain. The less there is of connexion between foregoing things and following ones, so much
the less there is between Means and end, Endeavours and success; and in the same proportion
are Means and Endeavours ineffectual and in vain.
It will follow from Arminian principles, that there is no degree of connexion between
virtue or vice, and any foregoing event or thing: or, in other words, that the determination
of the existence of virtue or vice does not in the least depend on the influence of any thing
that comes to pass antecedently, as its cause, Means, or ground; because, so far as it is so, it
is not from self-determination: and, therefore, so far there is nothing of the nature of virtue
or vice. And so it follows, that virtue and vice are not at all, in any degree, dependent upon,
or connected with, as, any foregoing event or existence, its cause, ground, or Means. And
if so, then all foregoing Means must be totally in vain.
Hence it follows, that there cannot, in any consistence with the Arminian scheme, be
any reasonable ground of so much as a conjecture concerning the consequence of any Means
and Endeavours, in order to escaping vice or obtaining virtue, or any choice or preference
of Means, as having a greater probability of success by some than others; either from any
natural connexion or dependence of the end on the Means, or through any divine constitu-
tion, or revealed way of God, bestowing or bringing to pass these things, in consequence of
any Means, Endeavours, Prayers, or Deeds. Conjectures, in this latter case, depend on a
supposition, that God himself is the Giver or determining Cause of the events sought: but
if they depend on self-determination, then God is not the determining or disposing Author
of them: and if these things are not of his disposal, then no conjecture can be made, from
any revelation he has given, concerning any method of his disposal of them.
Yea, on these principles, it will not only follow, that men cannot have any reasonable
ground of judgment or conjecture, that their Means and Endeavours to obtain virtue or
avoid vice will be successful, but they may be sure, they will not; they may be certain, that
they will be in vain; and that if ever the thing, which they seek, comes to pass, it will not be
at all owing to the Means they use. For Means and Endeavours can have no effect at all, in
order to obtain the end, but in one of these two ways: either, (1.) Through a natural tendency
and influence, to prepare and dispose the mind more to virtuous acts, either by causing the
disposition of the heart to be more in favour of such acts, or by bringing the mind more
into the view of powerful motives and inducements; or, (2.) By putting persons more in the
way of God’s bestowment of the benefit. But neither of these can be the case. Not the latter;
for, as has been just now observed, it does not consist with the Arminian notion of self-de-
termination, which they suppose essential to virtue, that God should be the bestower, or
(which is the same thing) the determining, disposing author of virtue. Not the former; for
703
SECTION V. Objections, that this scheme of Necessity renders all Means…