Appendix.5036
————————————
We do not deny that all these things which have been brought forward by you in oppos-
ition are contained in the writings of the annalists. For we have ourselves also, according to
the measure and capacity of our powers, read these same things, and know that they have
been alleged; but the whole discussion hinges upon this: whether these are gods who you
assert are furious when displeased, and are soothed by games and sacrifices, or are something
far different, and should be separated from the notion even of this, and from its power.
For who, in the first place, thinks or believes that those are gods who are lost in joyful
pleasure at theatrical shows5037 and ballets, at horses running to no purpose; who set out
from heaven to behold silly and insipid acting, and grieve that they are injured, and that the
honours due to them are withheld if the pantomimist halts for a little, or the player, being
wearied, rests a little; who declare that the dancer has displeased them if some guilty fellow
passes through the middle of the circus to suffer the penalty and punishment of his deeds?
All which things, if they be sifted thoroughly and without any partiality, will be found to be
alien not only to the gods, but to any man of refinement, even if he has not been trained to
the utmost gravity and self-control.5038
540
For, in the first place, who is there who would suppose that those had been, or believe
that they are, gods, who have a nature which tends to5039 mischief and fury, and lay these5040
aside again, being moved by a cup of blood and fumigation with incense; who spend days
of festivity, and find the liveliest pleasure in theatrical shows5041 and ballets; who set out
5036 This section, which is found in the ms. after the first sentence of ch. 44, was retained in the text of both
Roman editions, marked off, however, by asterisks in that of Ursinus, but was rejected by Gelenius and later
editors as the useless addition of some copyist. Oehler alone has seen that it is not “a collection of words gathered
carelessly and thoughtlessly” (Hildebrand), and maintained that we have in it the corrections of Arnobius
himself. If the three paragraphs are read carefully, it will be observed that the first is a transposition and recon-
struction of the first two sentences of ch. 39; the second a revision of the interrogations in ch. 41, but with the
sentence which there precedes placed after them here, whilst the third is made up of the same sentences in a
revised and enlarged form. Now this must be regarded as conclusive evidence against the hypothesis that these
sentences were originally scribbled carelessly on the margin, and afterwards accidentally incorporated in the
text. Cf. p. 532, n. 10.
5037 Lit., “motions.”
5038 Lit. “to the heights (apices) of gravity and weight,” i.e., of that constancy of mind which is not moved
by trifles.
5039 Lit., “of hurting and raging.”
5040 i.e., evil dispositions.
5041 Lit., “motions.”
Appendix.
1322
Appendix.