return according to his deserts may be given him?” To this we shall make answer, with our
eye fixed upon the consequences of that which we have already laid down, that this happiness
in the future, while it is in its essence a heritage of humanity, may at the same time be called
in one sense a recompense; and we will make clear our meaning by the same instance as
before. Let us suppose two persons suffering from an affection of the eyes; and that the one
surrenders himself most diligently to the process of being cured, and undergoes all that
Medicine can apply to him, however painful it may be; and that the other indulges without
restraint in baths1551 and wine-drinking, and listens to no advice whatever of his doctor as
to the healing of his eyes. Well, when we look to the end of each of these we say that each
duly receives in requital the fruits of his choice, the one in deprivation of the light, the other
in its enjoyment; by a misuse of the word we do actually call that which necessarily follows,
a recompense. We may speak, then, in this way also as regards this question of the infants:
we may say that the enjoyment of that future life does indeed belong of right to the human
being, but that, seeing the plague of ignorance has seized almost all now living in the flesh,
he who has purged himself of it by means of the necessary courses of treatment receives the
377
due reward of his diligence, when he enters on the life that is truly natural; while he who
refuses Virtue’s purgatives and renders that plague of ignorance, through the pleasures he
has been entrapped by, difficult in his case to cure, gets himself into an unnatural state, and
so is estranged from the truly natural life, and has no share in the existence which of right
belongs to us and is congenial to us. Whereas the innocent babe has no such plague before
its soul’s eyes obscuring1552 its measure of light, and so it continues to exist in that natural
life; it does not need the soundness which comes from purgation, because it never admitted
the plague into its soul at all. Further, the present life appears to me to offer a sort of analogy
to the future life we hope for, and to be intimately connected with it, thus; the tenderest in-
fancy is suckled and reared with milk from the breast; then another sort of food appropriate
to the subject of this fostering, and intimately adapted to his needs, succeeds, until at last
he arrives at full growth. And so I think, in quantities continually adapted to it, in a sort of
regular progress, the soul partakes of that truly natural life; according to its capacity and its
power it receives a measure of the delights of the Blessed state; indeed we learn as much
from Paul, who had a different sort of food for him who was already grown in virtue and
for the imperfect “babe.” For to the last he says, “I have fed you with milk, and not with
meat: for hitherto ye were not able to bear it1553.” But to those who have grown to the full
measure of intellectual maturity he says, “But strong meat belongeth to those that are of full
age, even those who by reason of use have their senses exercised…1554” Now it is not right
1551 For an explanation of such a restriction, see Bingham, vol. viii. p. 109 (ed. 1720).
1552 ἐπιπροσθούσης
1553 2 Cor. iii. 2.
1554 Heb. v. 14.
698
On Infants' Early Deaths.