AGAINST THE PELAGIANS.— BOOK III.
475
Testament, and have mostly spun an argu- ment something like this : Either God knew
that man, placed in Paradise, would trans-
gress His command, or He did not know.
If He knew, man is not to blame, who could
not avoid God's foreknowledge, but He Who created him such that he could not
escape the knowledge of God. If He did
not know, in stripping Him of foreknowledge
you also take away His divinity. Upon the
same showing God will be deserving of blame
for choosing Saul, who was to prove one of
the worst of kings. And the Saviour must be
convicted either of ignorance, or of unright-
eousness, inasmuch as He said in the Gospel,
" Did I not "choose you the twelve, and one of
you is a devil ? " Ask Him why He chose Judas a traitor? Why He entrusted to
him the bag when He knew that he was a
thief ? Shall I tell you the reason ? God
judges the present, not the future. He does
not make use of His foreknowledge to con-
demn a man though He knows that he will
hereafter displease Him ; but such is His
goodness and unspeakable mercy that He
chooses a man who, He perceives, will mean-
while be good, and who, He knows, will turn
out badly, thus giving him the opportunity of
being converted and of repenting. This is
the Apostle's meaning when he says,* " Dost thou not know that the goodness of God
leadeth thee to repentance? but after thy
hardness and impenitent heart treasures! up
for thyself wrath in the day of wratli and
revelation of the righteous judgment of God,
Who will render to every man according to
his works." For Adam did not sin because God knew that he would do so ; but God,
inasmuch as He is God, foreknew what Adam
would do of his own free choice. You may as well accuse God of falsehood because He
said by the mouth of Jonah : 3 " Yet three
days, and Nineveh shall be overthrown." But God will reply by the mouth of Jeremiah,
"At what instant I shall speak concerning a nation, and concerning a kingdom, to pluck
up, and to break down, and to destroy it ; if
that nation, concerning which I have spoken,
turn from their evil, I will repent of the evil
that I thought to do unto them. And at
what instant I shall speak concerning a nation,
and concerning a kingdom, to build and to
plant it ; if it do evil in my sight, that it obey
not my voice, then I will repent of the good,
wherewith I said I would benefit them." Jonah, on a certain occasion, was indignant
because, at God's command, he had spoken falsely ; but his sorrow was proved to be ill
founded, since he would rather speak truth
1 S. John vi. 70.
4 Jercm. xviii. 7, 3.
a Rom. ii. 4, 5.
3 in. 4.
and have a countless multitude perish, than
speak falsely and have them saved. His
position was thus illustrated : : " Thou grievest over the ivy (or gourd), for the which thou
hast not laboured, neither madest it grow,
which came up in a night, and perished in a
night ; and should not I have pity on Nineveh,
that great city, wherein are more than six score
thousand persons that cannot discern between
their right hand and their left hand ? " If there was so vast a number of children and
simple folk, whom you will never be able to
prove sinners, what shall we say of those
inhabitants of both sexes who were at dif-
ferent periods of life ? According to Philo,
and the wisest of philosophers, Plato (so the
" Timasus " tells us), in passing from infancy to decrepit old age, we go through seven
stages, which so gradually and so gently fol-
low one another that we are quite insensible of the change.
C. The drift of your whole argument is
this — what the Greeks call avrtgovaiov, and
we free will, you admit in terms, but in
effect destroy. For you make God the
author of sin, in asserting that man can of
himself do nothing, but that he must have
the help of God to Whom is imputed all we
do. But we say that, whether a man does
good or evil, it is imputed to him on account
of the faculty of free choice, inasmuch as he
did what he chose, and not to Him Who once
for all gave him free choice.
A. Your shuffling is to no purpose ; you are
caught in the snares of truth. For upon this
showing, even if He does not Himself assist,
according to you He will be the author of
evil, because He might have prevented it and did not. It is an old maxim that if a man
can deliver another from death and does not,
he is a homicide.
C. I withdraw and yield the point ; you
have won ; provided, however, that victory is
the subverting of the truth by specious words,
that is to say, not by truth, but by falsehood.
For I might make answer to you in the
Apostle's words, 2" Though I be rude in
speech, yet not in knowledge." When you speak, your rhetorical tricks are too much
for me, and I seem to agree with you ; but
when you stop speaking, it all goes out of
my he'ad, and I see quite clearly that your argument does not flow from the foun-
tains of truth and Christian simplicity, but
rests on the laboured subtleties of the
philosophers.
A. Do you wish me, then, once more to re-
sort 'to the evidence of Scripture ? If so, what becomes of the boast of your disciples
1 Jonah iv. 10, n. 8 i Cor. xi. 6.