those that were taken into the Jewish church. And as to the latter, he delivers it as his senti-
ment, (p. 24. a.) that the body of the people were not regenerate. So that, according to his
own sentiments, when the apostolical rule of taking in is observed, the body of those who
are admitted will be hypocrites.
Now therefore, I desire that this matter may be examined to the very bottom.—And
here let it be considered, whether the truth of the following things be not incontestable.
1. If indeed by the rule God has given for admissions, when it is carefully attended, more
unconverted persons will he admitted, than converted; then it will follow, That just such a
visibility or visible appearance of saintship as the rule requires, is more frequently without
real saintship, than with it.
2. If Mr. S. and Mr. W. had just reason from the Holy Scripture, and Divine Providence,
to think thus, and to publish such a sentiment, and the christian church has good reason to
believe them; then God has given the christian church in its present state (dark and imperfect
as it is) good reason to think so too.
3. If Christ by the rule he has given for admissions, requires his churches to receive such
a visibility or appearance, which he has given the same churches at the same time reason to
judge to be an appearance that for the most part is without godliness, or more frequently
connected with ungodliness; then he requires them to receive such an appearance, as he at
the same time has given them reason to think does not imply a probability of godliness, but
is attended rather with a probability of ungodliness. For that is the notion of probability;
an appearance, which so far as we have, means to judge, is for the most part connected with
the thing. 406 Therefore the sign or appearance, let it be what it will, implies a probability of
that which we have reason to think it is for the most part connected or attended with. Where
there is only probability without certainty, there is a peradventure in the case on both sides;
or in vulgar language, the supposition on both sides stands a chance to be true. But that side
which most commonly proves true in such a case, stands the best chance; and therefore
properly on that side lies the probability.
4. That cannot be a credible visibility or appearance, which is not a probable appearance.
To say, a thing is credible and not probable, is a contradiction. And it is impossible rationally
to judge a thing true, and at the same time rationally to judge a thing most probably not
406 Mr. Locke thus defines probability. (Hum. Und. 7th Edit 8vo. Vol. II. p. 273.) “Probability is nothing but
the appearance of such an agreement or disagreement, by the intervention of proofs, whose connexion is not
constant and immutable, or at least is not perceived to be so: but is. or appears for the most part to be so; and
is enough to induce the mind to judge the proposition to be true, or false, rather than the contrary. And Mr. W.
himself (p. 139.) says, “It is moral evidence of gospel sincerity, which God’s word makes the church’s rule,” &c.
Now does such an appearance, as we have reason at the same time to think is more frequently without gospel-
holiness than with it, amount to moral evidence of gospel-sincerity.”
1942
SECTION VI. Visibility without probability.