25. These things are recorded in regard to James, who is said to be the author of the first
of the so-called catholic528 epistles. But it is to be observed that it is disputed;529 at least,
not many of the ancients have mentioned it, as is the case likewise with the epistle that bears
528 This term was applied to all or a part of these seven epistles by the Alexandrian Clement, Origen, and
Dionysius, and since the time of Eusebius has been the common designation. The word is used in the sense of
“general,” to denote that the epistles are encyclical letters addressed to no particular persons or congregations,
though this is not true of II. and III. John, which, however, are classed with the others on account of their supposed
Johannine authorship, and consequent close connection with his first epistle. The word was not first used, as
some have held, in the sense of “canonical,” to denote the catholic or general acceptance of the epistle,—a
meaning which Eusebius contradicts in this very passage, and which the history of the epistles themselves (five
of the seven being among the antilegomena) sufficiently refutes. See Holtzmann’s Einleitung, p. 472 sqq., and
Weiss, ibid. p. 89 sqq.
529 νοθεύεται. It is common to translate the word νόθος, “spurious” (and the kindred verb, “to be spurious”);
but it is plain enough from this passage, as also from others that Eusebius did not employ the word in that sense.
He commonly used it in fact, in a loose way, to mean “disputed,” in the same sense in which he often employed
the word ἀντιλεγόμενος. Lücke, indeed, maintained that Eusebius always used the words νόθος and
ἀντιλεγόμενος as synonymous; but in Bk. III. chap. 25, as pointed out in note 1 on that chapter, he employed
the words as respective designations of two distinct classes of books. The Epistle of James is classed by Eusebius
(in Bk. III. chap. 25) among the antilegomena. The ancient testimonies for its authenticity are very few. It was
used by no one, except Hermas, down to the end of the second century. Irenæus seems to have known the epistle
(his works exhibit some apparent reminiscences of it), but he nowhere directly cites it. The Muratorian Fragment
omits it, but the Syriac Peshito contains it, and Clement of Alexandria shows a few faint reminiscences of it in
his extant works, and according to Eusebius VI. 14, wrote commentaries upon “Jude and the other catholic
epistles.” It is quoted frequently by Origen, who first connects it with the “Brother of the Lord,” but does not
express himself with decision as to its authenticity. From his time on it was commonly accepted as the work of
“James, the Lord’s brother.” Eusebius throws it among the antilegomena; not necessarily because he considered
it unauthentic, but because the early testimonies for it are too few to raise it to the dignity of one of the homo-
logoumena (see Bk. III. chap. 25, note 1). Luther rejected the epistle upon purely dogmatic grounds. The advanced
critical school are unanimous in considering it a post-apostolic work, and many conservative scholars agree
with them. See Holtzmann’s Einleitung, p. 475 sqq. and Weiss’ Einleitung, p. 396 sqq. The latter defends its au-
thenticity (i.e. the authorship of James, the brother of the Lord), and, in agreement with many other scholars
of conservative tendencies, throws its origin back into the early part of the fifties.
235
The Martyrdom of James, who was called the Brother of the Lord.