BOOK oS Ad,
ARGUMENT.
To vindicate the Christians from any charge of impiety because they
offered no sacrifices, Arnobius quotes Varro’s opinion, that the true gods
could not wish for these, whilst the images could care for nothing (1).
The true gods, though unknown because unseen, must be, so far as
their divinity is concerned, exactly alike, so as never to have been be-
gotten, or be dependent on anything external to themselves (2). But if
this is the case, on what ground ought sacrifices to be offered—as food
for the gods? but whatever needs help from without, must be liable to
perish if this is withheld. Moreover, unless the gods feed on the steam
and vapour of the sacrifices, it is plain that they receive nothing, as the
fire on the altar destroys what is placed on it; whilst, finally, if the
gods are incorporeal, it is difficult to see how they can be supported by
corporeal substances (3). It might indeed be supposed that the gods
took some pleasure in having victims slain to them ; but this is exposed
to two objections,—that to feel pleasure necessitates the capacity of
feeling pain, whilst these two states are becoming only in the weakness
of mortals, and require the possession of the senses, which can only
accompany a bodily form, from which the gods are supposed to be free ;
and that, secondly, to feel pleasure in the sufferings of animals, is hardly
consistent with the divine character (4). It was commonly held that
sacrifices propitiated the deities, and appeased their wrath. Against this
Arnobius protests as utterly inconsistent with the view of the divine
nature, which he conceives it necessary to maintain so persistently (5).
But conceding this point, for the sake of argument, two alternatives
are proposed : such sacrifices should be offered either before or after the
divine wrath is excited. If the former is chosen, this is to represent the
gods as wild beasts to be won from their savageness by throwing to them
sops, or that on which to vent their rage; if the latter, without waiting
to discuss whether the divine greatness would be offended by a creature
so ignorant and unimportant as man (6), or what laws the gods have
established on earth by the violation of which they might be enraged
(7), it is asked why the death of a pig, a chicken, or an ox should
change the disposition of a god, and whether the gods can be bribed into
a gracious mood. Moreover, if the divine pardon is not given freely, it
would be better to withhold it, as men sin more readily when they be-
504