Chapter VI.
Once more he challenges him to the profession of the Creed of Antioch.
The Creed then, O you heretic, of which we gave the text above, though it is that of all
the churches (for the faith of all is but one) is yet specially that of the city and Church of
Antioch, i.e., of that Church in which you were brought up, instructed, and regenerated.
The faith of this Creed brought you to the fountain of life, to saving regeneration, to the
grace of the Eucharist, to the Communion of the Lord: And what more! Alas for the grievous
and mournful complaint! Even to the ministerial office, the height of the presbyterate, the
dignity of the priesthood. Do you, you wretched madman, think that this is a light or trivial
matter? Do you not see what you have done? Into what a depth you have plunged yourself?
In losing the faith of the Creed, you have lost everything that you were. For the mysteries
of the priesthood and of your salvation rested on the truth of the Creed. Can you possibly
deny that? I say that you have denied your very self. But perhaps you think that you cannot
deny yourself. Let us look at the text of the Creed; that if you say what you used to do, you
may not be refuted, but if you say things widely different and contrary, you may not look
to be confuted by me, as you have condemned yourself already. For if you now maintain
something else than what is in the Creed and what you formerly maintained yourself, how
can you help ascribing your punishment to nobody but yourself, when you see that the
opinion of everybody else about you is the same as your own? “I believe,” the Creed says,
“in one God, the Father Almighty, Maker of all things visible and invisible; and in the Lord
Jesus Christ, His only begotten Son, the first-born of every creature; Begotten of Him before
all worlds, and not made.” It is well that you should first reply to this: Do you confess this
of Jesus Christ the Son of God, or do you deny it? If you confess it, everything is right enough.
But if not, how do you now deny what you yourself formerly confessed? Choose then which
you will: Of two things one must follow; viz., that that same confession of yours, if it still
holds good, should alone set you free, or if you deny it, be the first to condemn you. For you
said in the Creed: “I believe in one Lord Jesus Christ His only begotten Son, and the first-
born of every creature.” If the Lord Jesus Christ is the only begotten, and the first-born of
every creature, then by our own confession He is certainly God. For no other is the only
begotten and first-born of every creature but the only begotten Son of God: as He is the
first-born of the creatures, so He is also God the Creator of all. And how can you say that
He was a mere man at His birth from the Virgin, whom you confessed to be God before the
world. Next the Creed says: “Begotten of the Father before all worlds, and not made.” This
Creed was uttered by you. You said by your Creed, that Jesus Christ was begotten before
the worlds of God the Father, and not made. Does the Creed say anything about those
phantasms, of which you now rave? Did you yourself say anything about them? Where is
the statue? Where that instrument of yours, I pray? For God forbid that this should be an-
other’s and not yours. Where is it that you assert that the Lord Jesus Christ is like a statue,
Chapter VI. Once more he challenges him to the profession of the Creed of Antioch.
1495
Chapter VI. Once more he challenges him to the profession of the Creed of…