SECT. VI.
Concerning that objection against the doctrine which has been maintained, that it agrees
with the Stoical doctrine of Fate, and the opinions of Mr. Hobbes.
When Calvinists oppose the Arminian notion of the freedom of Will, and contingence of
volition, and insist that there are no acts of the Will, nor any other events whatsoever, but
what are attended with some kind of necessity; their opposers exclaim against them, as
agreeing with the ancient Stoics in their doctrine of Fate, and with Mr. Hobbes in his opinion
of Necessity.
It would not be worth while to take notice of so impertinent an objection, had it not
been urged by some of the chief Arminian writers.—There were many important truths
maintained by the ancient Greek and Roman philosophers, and especially the Stoics, that
are never the worse for being held by them. The Stoic philosophers, by the general agreement
of Christian divines, and even Arminian divines, were the greatest, wisest, and most virtuous
of all the heathen philosophers; and, in their doctrine and practice, came the nearest to
Christianity of any of their sects. How frequently are the sayings of these philosophers, in
many of the writings and sermons, even of Arminian divines, produced, not as arguments
for the falseness of the doctrines which they delivered, but as a confirmation of some of the
greatest truths of the christian religion, relating to the unity and perfections of the Godhead,
a future state, the duty and happiness of mankind, &c. and how the light of nature and
reason, in the wisest and best of the heathen, harmonized with and confirms the gospel of
Jesus Christ.
And it is very remarkable, concerning Dr. Whitby, that although he alleges the agreement
of the Stoics with us, wherein he supposes they maintained the like doctrine, as an argument
against the truth of ours; yet, this very Dr. Whitby alleges the agreement of the Stoics with
the Arminian, wherein he supposes they taught the same doctrine with them, as an argument
for the truth of their doctrine. 141 So that, when the Stoics agree with them, it is a confirm-
ation of their doctrine, and a confutation of ours, as showing that our opinions are contrary
to the natural sense and common reason of mankind: nevertheless, when the Stoics agree
with us, it argues no such thing in our favour; but, on the contrary, is a great argument
against us, and shows our doctrine to be heathenish!
It is observed by some Calvinistic writers, that the Arminians symbolize with the Stoics,
in some of those doctrines wherein they are opposed by the Calvinists; particularly in their
denying an original, innate, total corruption and depravity of heart; and in what the; held
of man’s ability to make himself truly virtuous and conformed to God, and in some other
doctrines.
141 Whitby on the five Points. Edit.3. p. 325, 326, 327.
SECTION VI. Concerning that objection against the doctrine which has been maintained, that it agrees with the Stoical doctrine of Fate, and the opinions of Mr. Hobbes.
706
SECTION VI. Concerning that objection against the doctrine which has been…