say that Julian died so soon because he gave back the basilicas to you. For we might be
equally prolix with you in this, but we are unwilling to be equally foolish. Well, then, as I
had begun to say, from these two we will take away Macarius. For when you had mentioned
the names of two, Macarius and Ursacius, you repeated the name of Ursacius with the view
of showing us how he deserved his death; and you said, "For Ursacius was slain in a battle
with the barbarians, after which birds of prey with their savage talons, and the greedy teeth
of dogs with their biting, tore him limb from limb." Whence it is quite clear, since it is your
583
custom to excite greater odium against us on account of Macarius, insomuch that you call
us not Ursacians but Macarians, that you would have been sure to say by far the most con-
cerning him, had you been able to say anything of the sort about his death. Of these two,
therefore, when you used the plural number, if you take away Macarius, there remains
Ursacius alone, a proper name of the singular number. Where is therefore the fulfillment
of your threatening and tremendous promise of so many who should support your argument?
209. By this time all men who are in any degree acquainted with the meaning of words
must understand, it seems to me, how ridiculous it is that, when you had said, "Macarius
perished, Ursacius perished, and all your counts perished in like manner, by the vengeance
of God," as though men were calling upon you to prove the fact, whereas, in reality, neither
hearer nor reader was calling on you for anything further whatsoever, you immediately
strung together a long argument in order to prove that all our counts perished in like manner
by the vengeance of God. "For Ursacius," you say, "was slain in a battle with the barbarians,
after which birds of prey with their savage talons, and the greedy teeth of dogs with their
biting, tore him limb from limb." In the same way, any one else, who was similarly ignorant
of the meaning of what he says, might assert that all your bishops perished in prison by the
vengeance of God; and when asked how he could prove this fact, he might at once add, For
Optatus, having been accused of belonging to the company of Gildo, was put to death in a
similar way. Frivolous charges such as these we are compelled to listen to, to consider, to
refute; only we are apprehensive for the weak, lest, from the greater slowness of their intellect,
they should fall speedily into your toils. But Ursacius, of whom you speak, if it be the case
that he lived a good life, and really died as you assert, will receive consolation from the
promise of God, who says, "Surely your blood of your lives will I require; at the hand of
every beast will I require it."2254
210. But as to the calumnious charges which you bring against us, saying that by us the
wrath of the kings of the world is excited against you, so long as we do not teach them the
lesson of holy Scripture, but rather suggest our own desire of war, I do not imagine that you
are so absolutely deaf to the eloquence of the sacred books themselves as that you should
not rather fear that they should be acquainted with it. But whether you so will or no, they
2254 Gen. ix. 5.
1150
Chapter 93