Chapter 6.—7. What then, ye Donatists, what have ye to say to this? If our opinion
about baptism is true, yet all who thought differently in the time of Cyprian were not cut
off from the unity of the Church, till God revealed to them the truth of the point on which
they were in error, why then have ye by your sacrilegious separation broken the bond of
peace? But if yours is the true opinion about baptism, Cyprian and the others, in conjunction
with whom ye set forth that he held such a Council, remained in unity with those who
thought otherwise; why, therefore, have ye broken the bond of peace? Choose which altern-
ative ye will, ye are compelled to pronounce an opinion against your schism. Answer me,
wherefore have ye separated yourselves? Wherefore have ye erected an altar in opposition
to the whole world? Wherefore do ye not communicate with the Churches to which
apostolic epistles have been sent, which you yourselves read and acknowledge, in accordance
with whose tenor you say that you order your lives? Answer me, wherefore have ye separated
yourselves? I suppose in order that ye might not perish by communion with wicked men.
How then was it that Cyprian, and so many of his colleagues, did not perish? For though
they believed that heretics and schismatics did not possess baptism, yet they chose rather
to hold communion with them when they had been received into the Church without bap-
tism, although they believed that their flagrant and sacrilegious sins were yet upon their
heads, than to be separated from the unity of the Church, according to the words of Cyprian,
"Judging no one, nor depriving any one of the right of communion if he differ from us."
8. If, therefore, by such communion with the wicked the just cannot but perish, the
Church had already perished in the time of Cyprian. Whence then sprang the origin of
Donatus? where was he taught, where was he baptized, where was he ordained, since the
Church had been already destroyed by the contagion of communion with the wicked? But
429
if the Church still existed, the wicked could do no harm to the good in one communion
with them. Wherefore did ye separate yourselves? Behold, I see in unity Cyprian and others,
his colleagues, who, on holding a council, decided that those who have been baptized without
the communion of the Church have no true baptism, and that therefore it must be given
them when they join the Church. But again, behold I see in the same unity that certain men
think differently in this matter, and that, recognizing in those who come from heretics and
schismatics the baptism of Christ, they do not venture to baptize them afresh. All of these
catholic unity embraces in her motherly breast, bearing each other’s burdens by turns, and
endeavoring to keep the unity of the Spirit in the bond of peace,1228 till God should reveal
to one or other of them any error in their views. If the one party held the truth, were they
infected by the others, or no? If the others held the truth, were they infected by the first, or
no? Choose which ye will. If there was contamination, the Church even then ceased to exist;
answer me, therefore, whence came ye forth hither? But if the Church remained, the good
1228 Eph. iv. 3.
Chapter 6
737
Chapter 6