age, acknowledges one principle,1543 but says that the prophecies1544 are from an opposing
spirit, being led to this view by the responses of a maiden by name Philumene,1545 who was
228
possessed by a demon.
1543 This means that Apelles accepted only one God, and made the creator but an angel who was completely
under the power of the Supreme God. Marcion, on the contrary, held, as said below, two principles, teaching
that the world-creator was himself a God, eternal, uncreated, and independent of the good God of the Christians.
It is true that Marcion represented the world-creator as limited in power and knowledge, and taught that the
Christian God would finally be supreme, and the world-creator become subject to him; but this, while it involves
Marcion in self-contradiction as soon as the matter is looked at theoretically, yet does not relieve him from the
charge of actual dualism. His followers were more consistent, and either accepted one principle, subordinating
the world-creator completely to the good God, as did Apelles, or else carried out Marcion’s dualism to its logical
result and asserted the continued independence of the Old Testament God and the world-creator, who was thus
very early identified with Satan and made the enemy of the Christian God. (Marcion’s world-creator was not
the bad God, but the righteous in distinction from the good God.) Still others held three principles: the good
God of the Christians, the righteous God or world-creator, and the bad God, Satan. The varying doctrines of
these schools explain the discrepant and often contradictory reports of the Fathers in regard to the doctrines of
Marcion. Apelles’ doctrine was a decided advance upon that of Marcion, as he rejected the dualism of the latter,
which was the destructive element in his system, and thus approached the Church, whose foundation must be
one God who rules the world for good. His position is very significant, as remarked by Harnack, because it shows
that one could hold Marcion’s fundamental principle without becoming a dualist.
1544 i.e. the Old Testament prophecies. Apelles in his Syllogisms (see below, note 28) exhibited the supposed
contradictions of the Old Testament in syllogistic form, tracing them to two adverse angels, of whom the one
spoke falsely, contradicting the truth spoken by the other. Marcion, on the other hand (in his Antitheses), referred
all things to the same God, the world-creator, and from the contradictions of the book endeavored to show his
vacillating and inconsistent character. He, however, accepted the Old Testament as in the main a trustworthy
book, but referred the prophecies to the Jewish Messiah in distinction from the Christ of the New Testament.
But Apelles, looking upon two adverse angels as the authors of the book, regarded it as in great part false. Marcion
and Apelles were one, however, in looking upon it as an anti-Christian book.
1545 This virgin, Philumene, is connected with Apelles in all the reports which we have of him (e.g. in Hip-
polytus, Tertullian, Jerome, &c.), and is reported to have been looked upon by Apelles as a prophetess who received
revelations from an angel, and who worked miracles. Tertullian, De Præscriptione, 6, evidently accepts these
miracles as facts, but attributes them to the agency of a demon. They all unite in considering her influence the
cause of Apelles’ heretical opinions. Tertullian (ibid. 30, &c.) calls her a prostitute, but the silence of Rhodo and
Hippolytus is sufficient refutation of such a charge, and it may be rejected as a baseless slander, like the report
of Apelles’ immorality mentioned in note 7. There is nothing strange in the fact that Apelles should follow the
535
Rhodo and his Account of the Dissension of Marcion.