Chapter XIII.—Simon Magus.360
1. But faith in our Saviour and Lord Jesus Christ having now been diffused among all
men,361 the enemy of man’s salvation contrived a plan for seizing the imperial city for
himself. He conducted thither the above-mentioned Simon,362 aided him in his deceitful
arts, led many of the inhabitants of Rome astray, and thus brought them into his own power.
360 It is justly remarked by Reuterdahl that no chapters of Eusebius’ History are so imperfect and unsatisfactory
as those which relate to heresies, but that this is to be ascribed more to the age than to the author. A right under-
standing of heresies and an appreciation of any truth which they might contain was utterly impossible to men
who looked upon heresy as the work of the devil, and all heretics as his chosen tools. Eusebius has been condemned
by some, because he gives his information about heretics only from second hand, and quotes none of them
directly; but it must be remembered that this method was by no means peculiar to Eusebius, and, moreover, it
is highly probable that he did not have access to any of their works. The accounts of the heretics given by Irenæus,
Hippolytus, and others would of course be preserved, but the writings of heretics themselves would be piously
excluded as completely as possible from all Christian libraries, and the knowledge of them cannot have remained
long in the Church. The sources upon which we have to rely at the present day for a knowledge of these heresies
furnish an illustration of this. We know them almost solely through their enemies, and Eusebius knew them in
the same way and very likely for the same reason.
361 See chap. 3, note 1.
362 Simon Magus, of whom mention is first made in Acts viii. 9 sqq. (quoted above, in chap. 1), played a very
prominent role in early Church history. His life has been so greatly embellished with legends that it is very dif-
ficult to extract a trustworthy account of him. Indeed the Tübingen school, as well as some other modern critics,
have denied altogether the existence of such a personage, and have resolved the account of him into a Jewish
Christian fiction produced in hostility to the apostle Paul, who under the mask of Simon was attacked as the
real heretic. But this identification of Paul and Simon rests upon a very slender foundation, as many passages
can be adduced in which the two are expressly distinguished, and indeed the thought of identifying Paul and
Simon seems never to have occurred to the writer of the Recognitions. The most that can be said is that the author
of the Homilies gives, and without doubt purposely, some Pauline traits to his picture of Simon, but this does
not imply that he makes Simon no more than a mask for Paul (cf. the words of Salmon in his article, Clementine
Literature, in the Dict. of Christ. Biog. Vol. I. p. 576). The original of Simon then is not to be found in Paul. The
third century fiction is based upon a real historic person whose actual existence must be assumed to account
for the early notices of him in the Acts and in Justin Martyr, as well as the common tradition of him among all
parties in the Church. Salmon considers Simon of Gitton—the basis of the account of Justin Martyr and of all
the later Simon legends—a second century Gnostic distinct from the Simon mentioned in the Acts (see his ex-
cellent article Simon Magus, in the Dict. of Christ. Biog. IV. p. 681 sqq.). In the Pseudo-Clementines Simon is
represented as traveling widely and spreading his errors in all directions, while Peter follows him for the purpose
of exposing his impostures, and refutes him repeatedly in public disputations, until at length he conquers him
completely in Rome, and Simon ends his life by suicide. His death, as well as his life, is recorded in various
conflicting and fabulous traditions (see note 9, below). For ancient accounts of Simon, see Justin Martyr, Apol.
Simon Magus.
194
Simon Magus.