Chapter 10.—15. But some one may say that the tares within may more easily be con-
verted into wheat. I grant that it is so; but what has this to do with the question of repeating
baptism? You surely do not maintain that if a man converted from heresy, through the oc-
casion and opportunity given by his conversion, should bear fruit before another who, being
within the Church, is more slow to be washed from his iniquity, and so corrected and
changed, the former therefore needs not to be baptized again, but the churchman to be
baptized again, who was outstripped by him who came from the heretics, because of the
greater slowness of his amendment. It has nothing, therefore, to do with the question now
at issue who is later or slower in being converted from his especial waywardness to the
straight path of faith, or hope, or charity. For although the bad within the fold are more
easily made good yet it will sometimes happen that certain of the number of those outside
will outstrip in their conversion certain of those within; and while these remain in barrenness,
the former, being restored to unity and communion, will bear fruit with patience, thirty-
fold, or sixty-fold, or a hundred-fold.1388 Or if those only are to be called tares who remain
in perverse error to the end, there are many ears of corn outside, and many tares within.
16. But it will be urged that the bad outside are worse than those within. It is indeed a
weighty question, whether Nicolaus, being already severed from the Church,1389 or Simon,
who was still within it,1390 was the worse,—the one being a heretic, the other a sorcerer.
But if the mere fact of division, as being the clearest token of violated charity, is held to be
the worse evil, I grant that it is so. Yet many, though they have lost all feelings of charity,
yet do not secede from considerations of worldly profit; and as they seek their own, not the
things which are Jesus Christ’s,1391 what they are unwilling to secede from is not the unity
of Christ, but their own temporal advantage. Whence it is said in praise of charity, that she
"seeketh not her own."1392
17. Now, therefore, the question is, how could men of the party of the devil belong to
the Church, which has no spot, or wrinkle, or any such thing,1393 of which also it is said,
"My dove is one?"1394 But if they cannot, it is clear that she groans among those who are
not of her, some treacherously laying wait within, some barking at her gate without. Such
men, however, even within, both receive baptism, and possess it, and transmit it holy in itself;
nor is it in any way defiled by their wickedness, in which they persevere even to the end.
1388 Matt. xiii. 23; Luke viii. 15.
1389 Rev. ii. 6.
1390 Acts viii. 9-24.
1391 Phil. ii. 21.
1392 1 Cor. xiii. 5.
1393 Eph. v. 27; Retract. ii. 18.
1394 Song of Sol. vi. 9.
Chapter 10
798
Chapter 10