believes [like Anaximenes] that the infinite air around us is the true God. What matters it
to such a man though he be ignorant what bodily form they speak of, since they speak of a
form which is bounded on all sides? What matters it to him whether it was only as an Aca-
demician, and merely for the purpose of confuting Anaximenes, who had said that God is
a material existence,—for air is material,—that Cicero objected that God must have form
and beauty?2403 or himself perceived that truth has immaterial form and beauty, by which
the mind itself is moulded, and by which we judge all the deeds of the wise man to be
beautiful, and therefore affirmed that God must be of the most perfect beauty, not merely
for the purpose of confuting an antagonist, but with profound insight into the fact that
nothing is more beautiful than truth itself, which is cognisable by the understanding alone,
and is immutable? Moreover, as to the opinion of Anaximenes, who held that the air is
generated, and at the same time believed it to be God, it does not in the least move the man
who understands that, since the air is certainly not God, there is no likeness between the
manner in which the air is generated, that is to say, produced by some cause, and the manner,
understood by none except through divine inspiration, in which He was begotten who is
the Word of God, God with God. Moreover, who does not see that even in regard to mater-
ial things he speaks most foolishly in affirming that air is generated, and is at the same time
God, while he refuses to give the name of God to that by which the air has been gener-
ated,—for it is impossible that it could be generated by no power? Yet once more, his saying
that the air is always in motion will have no disturbing influence as proof that the air is God
upon the man who knows that all movements of body are of a lower order than movements
of the soul, but that even the movements of the soul are infinitely slow compared with His
who is supreme and immutable Wisdom.
24. In like manner, if Anaxagoras or any other affirm that the mind is essential truth
and wisdom,2404 what call have I to debate with a man about a word? For it is manifest that
mind gives being to the order and mode of all things, and that it may be suitably called in-
finite with respect not to its extension in space, but to its power, the range of which transcends
all human thought. Nor [shall I dispute his assertion] that this essential wisdom is formless;
447
for this is a property of material things, that whatever bodies are infinite are also formless.
Cicero, however, from his desire to confute such opinions, as I suppose, in contending with
adversaries who believed in nothing immaterial, denies that anything can be annexed to
that which is infinite, because in things material there must be a boundary at the part to
2403 The words of Cicero are: “Post, Anaximenes æra Deum statuit, eumque gigni, esseque immensum, et
infinitum, et semper in motu: quasi aut ær sine ulla forma Deus esse possit, cum præsertim Deum non modo
aliqua sed pulcherrima specie esse deceat: aut non omne quod ortum sit mortalitas consequatur.”—De Natura
Deorum, Book 1.
2404 Ipsam veritatem atque sapientiam.
967
To Dioscorus