the same thing, amounts to invincible necessity; which surely is the highest kind of tendency,
or propensity: and that not the less, for his laying this propensity to our infirmityor weakness,
which may seem to intimate some defect, rather than any thing positive: and it is agreeable
to the sentiments of the best divines, that all sin originally comes from a defective or privative
cause. But sin does not cease to be sin, justly exposing to eternal ruin (as implied in Dr. T.’s
own words), for arising from infirmity or defect; nor does an invincible propensity to sin
cease to be a propensity to such demerit of eternal ruin, because the proneness arises from
such a cause.
It is manifest, that this tendency, which has been proved, does not consist in any partic-
ular external circumstances that persons are in, peculiarly influencing their minds; but is
inherent, and is seated in that nature which is common to all mankind, which they carry
with them wherever they go, and still remains the same, however circumstances may differ.
For it is implied in what has been proved, and shown to be confessed, that the same event
comes to pass in all circumstances. In God’s sight no man living can be justified; but all are
sinners, and exposed to condemnation. This is true of persons of all constitutions, capacities,
conditions, manners, opinions, and educations; in all countries, climates, nations, and ages;
and through all the mighty changes and revolutions, which have come to pass in the habitable
world.
We have the same evidence, that the propensity in this case lies in the nature of the
subject—and does not arise from any particular circumstances—as we have in any case
whatsoever; which is only by the effects appearing to be the same in all changes of time and
place, and under all varieties of circumstances. It is in this way only we judge, that any
151
propensities, which we observe in mankind , are seated in their nature, in all other cases.
It is thus we judge of the mutual propensity betwixt the sexes, or of the dispositions which
are exercised in any of the natural passions or appetites, that they truly belong to the nature
of man; because they are observed in mankind in general, through all countries, nations,
and ages, and in all conditions.
If any should say, Though it be evident that there is a tendency in the state of things to
this general event—that all mankind should fail of perfect obedience, and should sin, and
incur a demerit of eternal ruin; and also that this tendency does not lie in any distinguishing
circumstances of any particular people, person, or age—yet it may not lie in man’s nature,
but in the general constitution and frame of this world. Though the nature of man may be
good, without any evil propensity inherent in it; yet the nature and universal state of this
world may be full of so many and strong temptations, and of such powerful influence on
such a creature as man, dwelling in so infirm a body, &c. that the result of the whole may
be a strong and infallible tendency in such a state of things, to the sin and eternal ruin of
every one of mankind.
946
SECTION II. Universal sin proves a sinful propensity.