I say, Sir, I have often wished every one of them truly knew my real sense of my own conduct
in the affair, that the one and the other of the said councils are privy to. As I have long ap-
prehended it to be my duty, not only to humble myself before God, for what was unchristian
and sinful in my conduct before the said councils, but also to confess my faults to them, and
take shame to myself before them; so I have often studied with myself, in what manner it
was practicable for me to do it. When I understood that you, Sir, and Mr. Eaton, were to be
at Cold-Spring at the time of the late council, I resolved to improve the opportunity, fully
to open my mind there to you and him thereon; and thought that probably some method
might be then thought of, in which my reflections on myself, touching the matters above
hinted at, might be communicated to most, if not all, the gentlemen aforesaid, who did not
reside in this county. But you know, Sir, how difficult it was for us to converse together by
ourselves, when at Cold-Spring, without giving umbrage to that people; I therefore proposed
writing to you upon the matters, winch I had then opportunity only most summarily to
suggest; which you, Sir, signified would be agreeable to you. I therefore now undertake what
I then proposed, in which I humbly ask the divine aid; and that I may be made most freely
willing, fully to confess my sin and guilt to you and the world, in those instances, which I
have reason to suppose fell under your notice, as they were public and notorious transactions,
and on account whereof, therefore, you, Sir, and all others who had knowledge thereof, had
just cause to be offended at me.
And in the first place, Sir, I apprehend that, with the church and people of Northampton,
I sinned and erred exceedingly, in consenting and labouring, that there should be so early
a dismission of Mr. Edwards from his pastoral relation to us, even upon the supposition
that he was really in a mistake in the disputed point; not only because the dispute was upon
matters so very disputable in themselves, and at the greatest remove from fundamental, but
because Mr. Edwards so long had approved himself a most faithful and painful pastor to
the said church. He also changed his sentiments, in that point, wholly from a tender regard
to what appeared to him to be truth; and had made known his sentiments with great mod-
eration, and upon great deliberation, against all worldly motives, from mere fidelity to his
great Master, and a tender regard to the souls of his flock, as he had the highest reason to
judge. These considerations now seem to me sufficient; and would (if we had been of a right
spirit) have greatly endeared him to his people, and made us to the last degree reluctant to
part with him, and disposed us to the exercise of the greatest candour, gentleness, and
moderation. How much of the reverse whereof appeared in us I need not tell you, Sir, who
were an eye-witness of our temper and conduct.
And, although it does not become me to pronounce decisively, on a point so disputable,
as was then in dispute; yet I beg leave to say, that I really apprehend, that it is of the highest
moment to the body of this church, and to me in particular, most solicitously to inquire,
whether, like the Pharisees and lawyers in John Baptist’s time, we did not reject the counsel
258
CHAPTER XVIII. Letter to Mr. M'Cullock—to Mr. Erskine. Account of the troubles…