434 ON THE TRINITY. [bOOK XV.
stand, that as the Father has in Himself that the Holy Spirit
should proceed from Him, so has He given to the Son that
the same Holy Spirit should proceed from Him, and be both
apart from time : and that the Holy Spirit is so said to proceed
from the Father as that it be understood that His proceeding
also from the Son, is a property derived by the Son from the
Father. For if the Son has of the Father whatever He has,
then certainly He has of the Father, that the Holy Spirit pro-
ceeds also from Him. But let no one think of any times therein
which imply a sooner and a later; because these things are not
there at all. How, then, would it not be most absurd to call
Him the Son of both: when,just as generation from the Father,
without any changeableness of nature, gives to the Son essence,
without beginning of time ; so procession from both, without
any changeableness of nature, gives to the Holy Spirit essence
without beginning of time ? For while we do not say that
the Holy Spirit is begotten, yet we do not therefore dare to
say that He is unbegotten, lest any one suspect in this word
either two Fathers in that Trinity, or two who are not from
another. For the Father alone is not from another, and
therefore He alone is called unbegotten, not indeed in the
Scriptures, but in the usage of disputants, who employ such
language as they can on so great a subject. And the Son is
born of the Father, and the Holy Spirit proceeds from the
Father principally, and the Father giving it, without any
interval of time, in common from both. But He would be
called the Son of the Father and of the Son, if—a thing
abhorrent to the feeling of all sound minds—both had be-
gotten Him. Therefore the Spirit of both is not begotten of
both, but proceeds from both.
Chap, xxvii.—What it is that suffices here to solve the question why the Spirit is
not said to be begotten, and why the Father alone is unbegotten. What they
ought to do who do not understand these things.
48. But because it is most difficult to distinguish generation
from procession in that co-eternal, and equal, and incorporeal,
and ineffably unchangeable and indivisible Trinity, let it suf-
fice meanwhile to put before those who are not able to be
drawn on further, what we said upon this subject in a sermon
to be delivered in the ears of Christian people, and after saying