instruction, the soul shall have segregated itself from its contrary and hostile race, adorning
121
itself also with purer things; that otherwise it cannot be restored to its own substance. For
it is said: "If I had not come and spoken unto them, they had not had sin. But now that I
have come and spoken, and they have refused to believe me, they shall have no excuse for
their sin."245 Whence it is perfectly plain, that repentance has been given after the Saviour’s
advent, and after this knowledge of things, by which the soul can, as if washed in a divine
fountain from the filth and vices as well of the whole world as of the bodies in which the
same soul dwells, be restored to the kingdom of God whence it has gone forth. For it is said
by the apostle, that "the mind of the flesh is hostile to God; is not subject to the law of God,
neither indeed can be."246 Therefore it is evident from these things that the good soul seems
to sin not voluntarily, but by the doing of that which is not subject to the law of God. For
it likewise follows that "the flesh lusteth against the spirit and the spirit against the flesh; so
that ye may not do the things that ye will."247 Again: "I see another law in my members,
warring against the law of my mind and leading me captive in the law of sin and of death.
Therefore I am a miserable man; who shall deliver me from the body of this death, unless
it be the grace of God through our Lord Jesus Christ,"248 "through whom the world has been
crucified to me and I to the world?"249
22. Augustin said: I recognize and embrace the testimonies of the divine Scriptures,
and I will show in a few words, as God may deign to grant, how they are consistent with my
faith. I say that there was free exercise of will in that man who was first formed. He was so
made that absolutely nothing could resist his will, if he had willed to keep the precepts of
God. But after he voluntarily sinned, we who have descended from his stock were plunged
into necessity. But each one of us can by a little consideration find that what I say is true.
For today in our actions before we are implicated by any habit, we have free choice of doing
anything or not doing it. But when by that liberty we have done something and the pernicious
sweetness and pleasure of that deed has taken hold upon the mind, by its own habit the
mind is so implicated that afterwards it cannot conquer what by sinning it has fashioned
for itself. We see many who do not wish to swear, but because the tongue has already become
habituated, they are not able to prevent those things from going forth from the mouth which
we cannot but ascribe to the root of evil. For that I may discuss with you those words, which
as they do not withdraw from your mouth so may they be understood by your heart: you
swear by the Paraclete. If therefore you wish to find out experimentally whether what I say
245 John xv. 22.
246 Rom. viii. 7.
247 Gal. v. 17.
248 Rom. vii. 23-25.
249 Gal. v. 14.
201
Disputation of the Second Day.