whether it is correct or the reverse. But we will by a slight addition advance his statement
so as to make it consistent with godliness. For since, whether it be the word of wisdom, or
the word of knowledge, or faith, or help, or government, or aught else that is enumerated
in the lists of saving gifts, “all these worketh that one and the self-same Spirit, dividing to
every man severally as He will491,” we therefore do not reject the statement of Eunomius
when he says that the Spirit “co-operates with the faithful for understanding and contem-
plation of things appointed” by Him, because by Him all good teachings are appointed for
us. “Sounding an accompaniment to those who pray.” It would be foolish seriously to examine
the meaning of this expression, of which the ludicrous and meaningless character is at once
manifest to all. For who is so demented and beside himself as to wait for us to tell him that
the Holy Spirit is not a bell nor an empty cask sounding an accompaniment and made to
ring by the voice of him who prays as it were by a blow? “Leading us to that which is expedient
for us.” This the Father and the Son likewise do: for “He leadeth Joseph like a sheep492,”
and, “led His people like sheep493,” and, “the good Spirit leadeth us in a land of righteous-
ness494.” “Strengthening us to godliness.” To strengthen man to godliness David says is the
work of God; “For Thou art my strength and my refuge495,” says the Psalmist, and “the Lord
is the strength of His people496,” and, “He shall give strength and power unto His people497.”
If then the expressions of Eunomius are meant in accordance with the mind of the Psalmist,
they are a testimony to the Divinity of the Holy Ghost: but if they are opposed to the word
of prophecy, then by this very fact a charge of blasphemy lies against Eunomius, because he
sets up his own opinions in opposition to the holy prophets. Next he says, “Lightening souls
with the light of knowledge.” This grace also the doctrine of godliness ascribes alike to the
Father, to the Son, and to the Holy Ghost. For He is called a light by David498, and from
thence the light of knowledge shines in them who are enlightened. In like manner also the
cleansing of our thoughts of which the statement speaks is proper to the power of the Lord.
For it was “the brightness of the Father’s glory, and the express image of His person,” Who
“purged our sins499.” Again, to banish devils, which Eunomius says is a property of the
Spirit, this also the only-begotten God, Who said to the devil, “I charge thee500,” ascribes
491 1 Cor. xii. 11.
492 Ps. lxxx. 1.
493 Ps. lxxvii. 20.
494 Cf. Ps. cxliii. 10.
495 Cf. Ps. xxxi. 3
496 Ps. xxviii. 8.
497 Ps. lxviii. 35.
498 Ps. xxvii. 1.
499 Heb. i. 3.
500 Cf. S. Mark ix. 25
256
Lastly he displays at length the folly of Eunomius, who at times speaks…