58 ON THE TRINITY. [BOOK II.
same form only, but in many forms ; first in one form, then in
another ; He is both visible in Himself, because His substance
was visible to mortal eyes, when He had not yet taken our
flesh, and mortal, inasmuch as He is changeable. And so also
the Holy Spirit, who appeared at one time as a dove, and
another time as fire. Whence, they say, these texts do not
belong to the Trinity, but singularly and properly to the
Father only : " ISTow unto the King eternal, immortal, and
invisible, the only wise God
;
" and, "Who only hath immor-
tality, dwelling in the light which no man can approach unto
;
whom no man hath seen, nor can see."
16. Passing by, then, these reasoners, who are unable to
know the substance even of the soul, which is invisible, and
therefore are very far indeed from knowing that the substance
of the one and only God, that is, the Father and the Son and
the Holy Spirit, remains ever not only invisible, but also
unchangeable, and that hence it possesses true and real immor-
tality ; let us, who deny that God, whether the Father, or the
Son, or the Holy Spirit, ever appeared to bodily eyes, unless
through the corporeal creature made subject to His own power;
let us, I say—ready to be corrected, if we are reproved in a
fraternal and upright spirit, ready to be so, even if carped at
by an enemy, so that he speak the truth—in catholic peace
and with peaceful study inquire, whether God indiscriminately
appeared to our fathers before Christ came in the flesh, or
whether it was any one person of the Trinity, or whether
severally, as it were by turns.
Chap. X.
—
Whether God the Trinity indiscriminately appeared to the Fathers,
or. any one person of the Trinity. The appearing of God to Adam.
Of the same appearance. The Vision to Abraham.
17. And first, in that which is written in Genesis, viz. that
God spake with man whom He had formed out of the dust
;
if we set apart the figurative meaning, and treat it so as to
place faith in the narrative even, in the letter, it should appear
that God then spake with man in the appearance of a man.
This is not indeed expressly laid down in the book, but the
general tenor of its reading sounds in this sense, especially in
that which is written, that Adam heard the voice of the Lord
God, walking in the garden in the cool of the evening, and hid