Book XVII.
Faustus rejects Christ’s declaration that He came not to destroy the law and the prophets
but to fulfill them, on the ground that it is found only in Matthew, who was not present
when the words purport to have been spoken. Augustin rebukes the folly of refusing to
believe Matthew and yet believing Manichæus, and shows what the passage of scripture
really means.
1. Faustus said: You ask why we do not receive the law and the prophets, when Christ
said that he came not to destroy them, but to fulfill them. Where do we learn that Jesus said
this? From Matthew, who declares that he said it on the mount. In whose presence was it
said? In the presence of Peter, Andrew, James, and John—only these four; for the rest, in-
cluding Matthew himself, were not yet chosen. Is it not the case that one of these four—John,
namely—wrote a Gospel? It is. Does he mention this saying of Jesus? No. How, then, does
it happen that what is not recorded by John, who was on the mount, is recorded by Matthew,
who became a follower of Christ long after He came down from the mount? In the first
place, then, we must doubt whether Jesus ever said these words, since the proper witness is
silent on the matter, and we have only the authority of a less trustworthy witness. But, besides
this, we shall find that it is not Matthew that has imposed upon us, but some one else under
his name, as is evident from the indirect style of the narrative. Thus we read: "As Jesus
passed by, He saw a man, named Matthew, sitting at the receipt of custom, and called him;
and he immediately rose up, and followed Him."634 No one writing of himself would say,
He saw a man, and called him; and he followed Him; but, He saw me, and called me, and I
followed Him. Evidently this was written not by Matthew himself, but by some one else
under his name. Since, then, the passage already quoted would not be true even if it had
been written by Matthew, since he was not present when Jesus spoke on the mount; much
more is its falsehood evident from the fact that the writer was not Matthew himself, but
some one borrowing the names both of Jesus and of Matthew.
2. The passage itself, in which Christ tells the Jews not to think that He came to destroy
the law, is rather designed to show that He did destroy it. For, had He not done something
of the kind, the Jews would not have suspected Him. His words are: "Think not that I am
235
come to destroy the law." Suppose the Jews had replied, What actions of thine might lead
us to suspect this? Is it because thou exposest circumcision, breakest the Sabbath, discardest
sacrifices, makest no distinction in foods? this would be the natural answer to the words,
Think not. The Jews had the best possible reason for thinking that Jesus destroyed the law.
If this was not to destroy the law, what is? But, indeed, the law and the prophets consider
themselves already so faultlessly perfect, that they have no desire to be fulfilled. Their author
and father condemns adding to them as much as taking away anything from them; as we
634 Matt. ix. 9.
Faustus rejects Christ’s declaration that He came not to destroy the law and the prophets but to fulfill them, on the ground that it is found only in Matthew, who was not present when the words purport to have been spoken. Augustin rebukes the folly of refusing to believe Matthew and yet believing Manichæus, and shows what the passage of scripture really means.
400
Faustus rejects Christ’s declaration that He came not to destroy the law…