Chapter LXXIII.
He proceeds to repeat himself, and after saying a great deal which he had said before,
and ridiculing the birth of God from a virgin,—to which we have already replied as we best
could,—he adds the following: “If God had wished to send down His Spirit from Himself,
what need was there to breathe it into the womb of a woman? For as one who knew already
how to form men, He could also have fashioned a body for this person, without casting His
own Spirit into so much pollution; 4655 and in this way He would not have been received
with incredulity, if He had derived His existence immediately from above.” He had made
these remarks, because he knows not the pure and virgin birth, unaccompanied by any
corruption, of that body which was to minister to the salvation of men. For, quoting the
sayings of the Stoics, 4656 and affecting not to know the doctrine about “things indifferent,”
he thinks that the divine nature was cast amid pollution, and was stained either by being in
the body of a woman, until a body was formed around it, or by assuming a body. And in
this he acts like those who imagine that the sun’s rays are polluted by dung and by foul-
smelling bodies, and do not remain pure amid such things. If, however, according to the
view of Celsus, the body of Jesus had been fashioned without generation, those who beheld
the body would at once have believed that it had not been formed by generation; and yet
an object, when seen, does not at the same time indicate the nature of that from which it
607
has derived its origin. For example, suppose that there were some honey (placed before
one) which had not been manufactured by bees, no one could tell from the taste or sight
that it was not their workmanship, because the honey which comes from bees does not make
known its origin by the senses, 4657 but experience alone can tell that it does not proceed
from them. In the same way, too, experience teaches that wine comes from the vine, for
taste does not enable us to distinguish (the wine) which comes from the vine. In the same
manner, therefore, the visible 4658 body does not make known the manner of its existence.
And you will be induced to accept this view, 4659 by (regarding) the heavenly bodies, whose
existence and splendour we perceive as we gaze at them; and yet, I presume, their appearance
does not suggest to us whether they are created or uncreated; and accordingly different
opinions have existed on these points. And yet those who say that they are created are not
agreed as to the manner of their creation, for their appearance does not suggest it, although
the force of reason 4660 may have discovered that they are created, and how their creation
was effected.
4655 εἰς τοσοῦτον μίασμα.
4656 Cf. book iv. capp. xiv. and lxviii.
4657 τῇ αἰσθήσει τὴν ἀρχὴν.
4658 τὸ αἰσθητὸν σῶμα.
4659 προσαχθήσῃ δὲ τῷ λεγομένῳ.
4660 κἃν βιασάμενος ὁ λόγος εὕρῃ.
Chapter LXXIII
1407
Chapter LXXIII