XV. That the soul proper, in fact and name, is the rational soul, while the others are called
so equivocally; wherein also is this statement, that the power of the mind extends throughout
the whole body in fitting contact with every part1642.
1. Now, if some things in creation possess the nutritive faculty, and others again are
regulated by the perceptive faculty, while the former have no share of perception nor the
latter of the intellectual nature, and if for this reason any one is inclined to the opinion of
a plurality of souls, such a man will be positing a variety of souls in a way not in accordance
with their distinguishing definition. For everything which we conceive among existing
things, if it be perfectly that which it is, is also properly called by the name it bears: but of
that which is not every respect what it is called, the appellation also is vain. For instance:—if
one were to show us true bread, we say that he properly applies the name to the subject: but
if one were to show us instead that which had been made of stone to resemble the natural
bread, which had the same shape, and equal size, and similarity of colour, so as in most
points to be the same with its prototype, but which yet lacks the power of being food, on
this account we say that the stone receives the name of “bread,” not properly, but by a mis-
nomer, and all things which fall under the same description, which are not absolutely what
they are called, have their name from a misuse of terms.
2. Thus, as the soul finds its perfection in that which is intellectual and rational,
everything that is not so may indeed share the name of “soul,” but is not really soul, but a
certain vital energy associated with the appellation of “soul1643.” And for this reason also
He Who gave laws on every matter, gave the animal nature likewise, as not far removed
from this vegetative life1644, for the use of man, to be for those who partake of it instead of
herbs:—for He says, “Ye shall eat all kinds of flesh even as the green herb1645;” for the per-
ceptive energy seems to have but a slight advantage over that which is nourished and grows
without it. Let this teach carnal men not to bind their intellect closely to the phenomena of
sense, but rather to busy themselves with their spiritual advantages, as the true soul is found
in these, while sense has equal power also among the brute creation.
3. The course of our argument, however, has diverged to another point: for the subject
of our speculation was not the fact that the energy of mind is of more dignity among the
attributes we conceive in man than the material element of his being, but the fact that the
1642 Otherwise chap. xvi. The Bodleian ms. of the Latin version gives the title:—“That the vital energy of the
irrational creatures is not truly but equivocally called ‘soul’, and of the unspeakable communion of body and
soul.”
1643 τῇ τῆς ψυχῆς κλήσει συγκεκριμένη. The meaning is apparently something like that given; but if we
might read συγκεχρημένη the sense of the passage would be much plainer.
1644 Reading φυτικής for φυσικῆς as before, ch. 8, §4 (where see note).
1645 Cf. Gen. ix. 3. The quotation, except the last few words, is not verbally from the LXX.
That the soul proper, in fact and name, is the rational soul, while the others are called so equivocally; wherein also is this statement, that the power of the mind extends throughout the whole body in fitting contact with every part.
746
That the soul proper, in fact and name, is the rational soul, while the…