the former. Eusebius feels called upon to answer the work, but confines himself entirely to
that part of it which concerned Christ and Apollonius, leaving to some future time a refut-
ation of the remainder of the work, which indeed, he says, as a mere reproduction of the
arguments of Celsus, had been already virtually answered by Origen (see chap. 1). Eusebius
admits that Apollonius was a good man, but refuses to concede that he was anything more,
or that he can be compared with Christ. He endeavors to show that the account of Apollonius
given by Philostratus is full of contradictions and does not rest upon trustworthy evidence.
The tone of the book is mild, and the arguments in the main sound and well presented. It
is impossible to fix the date of the work with any degree of certainty. Valesius assigns it to
the later years of the persecution, when Eusebius visited Egypt; Stein says that it may have
been written about 312 or 313, or even earlier; while Lightfoot simply remarks, “it was
probably one of the earliest works of Eusebius.” There is no ground for putting it at one
time rather than another except the intrinsic probability that it was written soon after the
work to which it was intended to be a reply. In fact, had a number of years elapsed after the
publication of Hierocles’ attack, Eusebius would doubtless, if writing against it at all, have
given a fuller and more complete refutation of it, such as he suggests in the first chapter that
he may yet give. The work of Hierocles, meanwhile, must have been written at any rate some
time before the end of the persecution, for it is mentioned in Lactantius’ Div. Inst. V. 2.
Eusebius’ work has been published by Gaisford: Eusebii Pamph. contra Hieroclem et
Marcellum libri, Oxon. 1852; and also in various editions of the works of Philostratus. Migne,
Opera IV. 795 sq., reprints it from Olearius’ edition of Philostratus’ works (Lips. 1709).
Against Porphyry(κατὰ Πορφυρίον). Porphyry, the celebrated Neo-Platonic philosopher,
regarded by the early Fathers as the bitterest and most dangerous enemy of the Church,
wrote toward the end of the third century a work against Christianity in fifteen books, which
was looked upon as the most powerful attack that had ever been made, and which called
forth refutations from some of the greatest Fathers of the age: from Methodius of Tyre,
Eusebius of Cæsarea, and Apollinaris of Laodicea; and even as late as the end of the fourth
or beginning of the fifth century the historian Philostorgius thought it necessary to write
another reply to it (see his H. E. X. 10). Porphyry’s work is no longer extant, but the fragments
of it which remain show us that it was both learned and skillful. He made much of the alleged
33
contradictions in the Gospel records, and suggested difficulties which are still favorite
weapons in the hands of skeptics. Like the work of Porphyry, and all the other refutations
of it, the Apology of Eusebius has entirely perished. It is mentioned by Jerome (de vir. ill.
81 and Ep. ad Magnum, §3, Migne’s ed. Ep. 70), by Socrates (H. E. III. 23), and by Philostor-
gius (H. E. VIII. 14). There is some dispute as to the number of books it contained. In his
Ep. ad Magn. Jerome says that “Eusebius et Apollinaris viginti quinque, et triginta volumina
condiderunt,” which implies that it was composed of twenty-five books; while in his de ver.
ill. 81, he speaks of thirty books, of which he had seen only twenty. Vallarsi says, however,
51
Catalogue of his Works.