LETTERS XLVIII.-XLIX.
79
mere phantom of one, and I will explain
how the holy Mary can be at once a mother
and a virgin. A mother before she was
wedded, she remained a virgin after bearing
her son. Therefore, as I was going to say,
the virgin Christ and the virgin Mary have dedicated in themselves the first fruits of
virginity for both sexes.1 The apostles have either been virgins or, though married, have
lived celibate lives. Those persons who are
chosen to be bishops, priests, and deacons
are either virgins or widowers; or at least,
when once they have received the priest-
hood, are vowed to perpetual chastity. Why
do we delude ourselves and feel vexed if,
while we are continually straining after sex-
ual indulgence, we find the palm of chastity
denied to us? We wish to fare sumptuously,
and to enjoy the embraces of our wives, yet
at the same time we desire to reign with
Christ among virgins and widows. Shall
there be but one reward, then, for hunger
and for excess, for filth and for finery, for
sackcloth and for silk? Lazarus,2 in his lifetime, received evil things, and the rich
man, clothed in purple, fat and sleek, while
he lived enjoyed the good things of the flesh ;
but, now that they are dead, they occupy
different positions. Misery has given place
to satisfaction, and satisfaction to misery. And it rests with us whether we will follow
Lazarus or the rich man.
LETTER XLIX.
TO PAMMACHIUS.
Jerome encloses the preceding letter, thanks Pam-
machius for his efforts to suppress his treatise " against
Jovinian," but declares these to be useless, and ex- horts him, if he still has any hesitation in his mind, to
turn to the Scriptures and the commentaries made
upon them by Origen and others. Written at the
same time as the preceding letter.
i. Christian modesty sometimes requires
us to be silent even to our friends, and to
nurse our humility in peace, where the re-
newal of an old friendship would expose us
to the charge of self-seeking. Thus, when
you have kept silence I have kept silence
too, and have not cared to remonstrate with
you, lest I should be thought more anxious
to conciliate a person of influence than to
cultivate a friend. But, now that it has be-
come a duty to reply to your letter, I will
endeavor always to be beforehand with you,
and not so much to answer your queries as
to write independently of them. Thus, if I
have shown my modesty hitherto by silence,
1 Cf. Letter XXII. § 18. 2 Luke xvi. 19-25.
I will henceforth show it still more by com-
ing forward to speak.
2. I quite recognize the kindness and
forethought which have induced you to with-
draw from circulation some copies of my
work against Jovinian. Your diligence,
however, has been of no avail, for several
people coming from the city have repeatedly
read aloud to me passages which they have
come across in Rome. In this province,
also, the books have already been circulated ;
and, as you have read yourself in Horace,
"Words once uttered cannot be recalled." I am not so fortunate as are most of the
writers of the day^able, that is, to correct
my trifles whenever I like. When once I
have written anything, either my admirers
or my ill-wishers — from different motives,
but with equal zeal — sow my work broad-
cast among the public; and their language,
whether it is that of eulogy or of criticism,
is apt to run to excess.2 They are guided not by the merits of the piece, but by their
own angry feelings. Accordingly, I have
done what I could. I have dedicated to you
a defence of the work in question, feeling
sure that when you have read it you will
yourself satisfy the doubts of others on my
behalf; or else, if you too turn up your nose
at the task, you will have to explain in some
new manner that section of the apostle3 in which he discusses virginity and marriage.
3. I do not speak thus that I may provoke
you to write on the subject yourself— although I know your zeal in the study of the
sacred writings to be greater than my own —
but that you may compel my tormentors to
do so. They are educated; in their own
eyes no mean scholars; competent not
merely to censure but to instruct me. If
they write on the subject, my view will be
the sooner neglected when it is compared
with theirs. Read, I pray you, and dili-
gently consider the words of the apostle,
and you will then see that — with a view to
avoid misrepresentation — I have been much
more gentle towards married persons than
he was disposed to be. Origen, Dionysius,
Pierius, Eusebius of Caesarea, Didymus,
Apollinaris, have used great latitude in the
interpretation of this epistle.4 When Pie-
rius, sifting and expounding the apostle's
meaning, comes to the words, " I would that
all men were even as I myself," 6 he makes
this comment upon them: "In saying this
Paul plainly preaches abstinence from mar-
1 Hor. AP. 390.
2 See the Preface to Jerome's Cdmm. on Daniel. 3 i Cor. vii. 4 i Corinthians. 5 i Cor. vii. 7.