nexions were included in the list of offenders, was the occasion of the alteration or not, it
is certain that, before the day appointed for the meeting of the committee arrived, a great
number of heads of families altered their minds, and declared they did not think proper to
proceed as they had begun, and that their children should not be called to an account in
such a way for such conduct; and the town was suddenly all in a blaze. This strengthened
the hands of the accused : some refused to appear; others who did appear, behaved with a
great degree of insolence, and contempt of the authority of the church; and little or nothing
could be done further in the affair.
This was the occasion of weakening Mr. Edwards’s hands in the work of the ministry,
especially among the young people, with whom, by this means, he greatly lost his influence.
It seemed in a great measure to put an end to his usefulness at Northampton, and doubtless
laid a foundation for his removal, and will help to account for the surprising events which
we are about to relate. He certainly had no great visible success after this; the influences of
the Holy Spirit were chiefly withheld, and stupidity and worldly-mindedness were greatly
increased among them. That great and singular degree of good order, sound morals, and
visible religion, which had for years prevailed at Northampton, soon began gradually to
decay, and the young people obviously became from that time more dissolute. 35
There was another difficulty of a far more serious nature. The church of Northampton,
like the other early churches of New England, was formed on the plan of strict communion:
in other words, none were admitted to the Lord’s supper, but those who, after due examin-
ation, were regarded as regenerate persons. Such was the uniform practice of the church
from its formation during the ministry of Mr. Mather, and for a considerable period after
the settlement of Mr. Stoddard, the predecessor of Mr. Edwards. Mr. Stoddard publicly
avowed a change in his opinions in 1704, when he had been in the ministry at Northampton
thirty-two years, and endeavoured at that time to introduce a corresponding change in the
practice of the church. He then declared himself, in the language of Dr. Hopkins, to be “of
the opinion, that unconverted persons, considered as such, had a right in the sight of God,
or by his appointment, to the sacrament of the Lord’s supper; that thereby it was their duty
to come to that ordinance, though they knew they had no true goodness or evangelical
holiness. He maintained that visible Christianity does not consist in a profession, or appear-
ance of that wherein true holiness, or real Christianity, consists; that therefore the profession,
which persons make, in order to be received as visible members of Christ’s church, ought
not to be such as to express or imply a real compliance with, or consent to, the terms of this
35 What an awful warning to all professors, and especially to young people! Behold, how great a matter a little
fire kindleth! Little do the giddy and the gay think how their levitics operate, and what seeds of distress and
sorrow they are sowing for themselves and others. Woe unto you that thus laugh now, for ye shall mourn and
weep! How desirable it should be penitentially here, and not despairingly hereafter. Dr. Williams.
235
CHAPTER XVI. Commencement of difficulties at Northampton