52. And yet, lest you should suppose that none but yourselves can make use of conjectures
and surmises, we too are able to bring them forward as well,3760 as your question is appro-
priate to either side.3761 Whence, you say, are men; and what or whence are the souls of
these men? Whence, we will ask, are elephants, bulls, stags, mules,3762 asses? Whence lions,
horses, dogs, wolves, panthers; and what or whence are the souls of these creatures? For it
is not credible that from that Platonic cup,3763 which Timæus prepares and mixes, either
their souls came, or that the locust,3764 mouse, shrew, cockroach, frog, centipede, should
be believed to have been quickened and to live, because3765 they have a cause and origin of
birth in3766 the elements themselves, if there are in these secret and very little known
means3767 for producing the creatures which live in each of them. For we see that some of
the wise say that the earth is mother of men, that others join with it water,3768 that others
add to these breath of air, but that some say that the sun is their framer, and that, having
been quickened by his rays, they are filled with the stir of life.3769 What if it is not these,
and is something else, another cause, another method, another power, in fine, unheard of
and unknown to us by name, which may have fashioned the human race, and connected it
with things as established;3770 may it not be that men sprang up in this way, and that the
cause of their birth does not go back to the Supreme God? For what reason do we suppose
that the great Plato had—a man reverent and scrupulous in his wisdom—when he withdrew
the fashioning of man from the highest God, and transferred it to some lesser deities, and
3760 Lit., “utter the same (conjectures),” easdem, the reading of LB. and Hildebrand, who says that it is so in
the ms.; while Crusius asserts that the ms. has idem, which, with Orelli’s punctuation, gives—“we have the same
power; since it is common (i.e., a general right) to bring forth what you ask,” i.e., to put similar questions.
3761 i.e., may be retorted upon you.
3762 Here, as elsewhere, instead of muli, the ms. reads milvi—“kites.”
3763 Cf. Plato, Timæus, st. p. 41, already referred to.
3764 Or, perhaps, “cray-fish,” locusta.
3765 The ms. reads quidem—“indeed,” retained by the first four edd., but changed into quia—“because,” by
Elmenhorst, LB., and Orelli, while Oehler suggests very happily si quidem—“if indeed,” i.e., because.
3766 Lit., “from.”
3767 Rationes.
3768 Cf. chs. 9 and 10 [p. 416, supra.].
3769 Orelli, retaining this as a distinct sentence, would yet enclose it in brackets, for what purpose does not
appear; more especially as the next sentence follows directly from this in logical sequence.
3770 Lit., “the constitutions of things.”
Chapter LII.
1055
Chapter LII.