tendency of any error. Why are we to blame, for saying what the Bible has taught us to say,
or for believing what the Holy Ghost has taught us to that end that we might believe it?
2. The adverse scheme lays another foundation of man’s salvation than God hath laid.
I do not now speak of that ineffectual redemption that they suppose to be universal, and
what all mankind are equally subjects of; but, I say, it lays entirely another foundation of
man’s actual, discriminating salvation, or that salvation wherein true Christians differ from
wicked men. We suppose the foundations of this to be Christ’s worthiness and righteousness:
on the contrary, that scheme supposes it to be men’s own virtue; even so, that this is the
ground of a saving interest in Christ itself. It takes away Christ out of the place of the bottom
stone, and puts in men’s own virtue in the room of him: so that Christ himself in the affair
of distinguishing actual salvation, is laid upon this foundation. And the foundation being
so different, I leave it to every out to judge whether the difference between the two schemes
consists only in punctilios of small consequence. The foundation being contrary, makes the
whole scheme exceeding diverse and opposite; the one is a gospel scheme, the other a legal
one.
3. It is in this doctrine that the most essential difference lies between the covenant of
grace and the first covenant. The adverse scheme of justification supposes that we are justified
by our works, in the very same sense wherein man was to have been justified by his works
under the first covenant. By that covenant our first parents were not to have had eternal life
given them for any proper merit in their obedience; because their perfect obedience was a
debt that they owed God. Nor was it to be bestowed for any proportion between the dignity
of their obedience, and the value of the reward; but only it was to be bestowed from a regard
to a moral fitness in the virtue of their obedience, to the reward of God’s favour; and a title
to eternal life was to be given them, as a testimony of God’s pleasedness with their works,
or his regard to the inherent beauty of their virtue. And so it is the very same way that those
in the adverse scheme suppose that we are received into God’s special favour now, and to
those saving benefits that are the testimonies of it. I am sensible the divines of that side en-
tirely disclaim the popish doctrine of merit; and are free to speak of our utter unworthiness,
653
and the great imperfections of all our services. But after all, it is our virtue, imperfect as it
is, that recommends men to God, by which good men come to have a saving interest in
Christ, and God’s favour, rather than others; and these things are bestowed in testimony of
God’s respect to their goodness. So that whether they will allow the term merit or no, yet
they hold, that we are accepted by our own merit, in the same sense, though not in the same
degree, as under the first covenant.
But the great and most distinguishing difference between that covenant and the covenant
of grace is, that by the covenant of grace we are not thus justified by our own works, but
only by faith in Jesus Christ. It is on this account chiefly that the new covenant deserves the
name of a covenant of grace, as is evident by Rom. iv. 16. “Therefore it is of faith, that it
2462
DISCOURSE. II. Pressing into the Kingdom of God.