Chapter XXXVI.
Celsus in the next place, producing from history other than that of the divine record,
those passages which bear upon the claims to great antiquity put forth by many nations, as
the Athenians, and Egyptians, and Arcadians, and Phrygians, who assert that certain indi-
viduals have existed among them who sprang from the earth, and who each adduce proofs
of these assertions, says: “The Jews, then, leading a grovelling life 3838 in some corner of
Palestine, and being a wholly uneducated people, who had not heard that these matters had
been committed to verse long ago by Hesiod and innumerable other inspired men, wove
together some most incredible and insipid stories, 3839 viz., that a certain man was formed
by the hands of God, and had breathed into him the breath of life, and that a woman was
taken from his side, and that God issued certain commands, and that a serpent opposed
these, and gained a victory over the commandments of God; thus relating certain old wives’
fables, and most impiously representing God as weak at the very beginning (of things), and
unable to convince even a single human being whom He Himself had formed.” By these
instances, indeed, this deeply read and learned Celsus, who accuses Jews and Christians of
ignorance and want of instruction, clearly evinces the accuracy of his knowledge of the
chronology of the respective historians, whether Greek or Barbarian, since he imagines that
Hesiod and the “innumerable” others, whom he styles “inspired” men, are older than Moses
and his writings—that very Moses who is shown to be much older than the time of the
Trojan war! It is not the Jews, then, who have composed incredible and insipid stories re-
garding the birth of man from the earth, but these “inspired” men of Celsus, Hesiod and
his other “innumerable” companions, who, having neither learned nor heard of the far older
and most venerable accounts existing in Palestine, have written such histories as their
Theogonies, attributing, so far as in their power, “generation” to their deities, and innumer-
able other absurdities. And these are the writers whom Plato expels from his “State” as being
corrupters of the youth, 3840—Homer, viz., and those who have composed poems of a sim-
ilar description! Now it is evident that Plato did not regard as “inspired” those men who
had left behind them such works. But perhaps it was from a desire to cast reproach upon
us, that this Epicurean Celsus, who is better able to judge than Plato (if it be the same Celsus
who composed two other books against the Christians), called those individuals “inspired”
whom he did not in reality regard as such.
3838 συγκύψαντες.
3839 ἀμουσότατα.
3840 Cf. Plato, de Repub., book ii. etc.
Chapter XXXVI
1165
Chapter XXXVI