them? I answer, Our Organs, and the motions in them and to them, exist in the manner
explained above.
“Plato, in his ‘Subterranean Cave,’ so famously known, and so elegantly described by
him, supposes men tied with their backs towards the Light, placed at a great distance from
them, so that they could not turn about their heads to it neither, and therefore could see
nothing but the shadows of certain substances behind them, projected from it; which
shadows they concluded to be the only substance and realities. And when they heard of
sounds made by those bodies, that were betwixt the Light and them, or their reverberated
ccxix
echoes, they imputed them to those shadows which they say. All this is a description of the
state of those men, who take Body to be the only Real and Substantial Thing in the world,
and to do all that is done in it; and therefore often impute Sense, Reason, and Understanding,
to nothing but Blood and Brains in us.”
CUDWORTH’S INTELLECTUAL SYSTEM.
[9.] Space. Space, as has been already observed, is a necessary being, if it may be called
a being; and yet we have also shown, that all existence is mental, that the existence of all
exterior things is ideal. Therefore it is a necessary being, only as it is a necessary idea, so far
as it is simple idea, that is necessarily connected with other simple exterior ideas, and is, as
it were, their common substance or subject. It is in the same manner a necessary being, as
any thing external is a being.
Coroll. It is hence easy to see in what sense that is true, that has been held by some, That,
when there is nothing between any two bodies, they unavoidably must touch.
[13.] The real and necessary existence of Space, and its Infinity, even beyond the Universe,
depend upon a like reasoning as the Extension of Spirits, and to the supposition of the
reality of the existence of a Successive Duration, before the Universe: even the impossibility
of removing the idea out of the mind. If it be asked, If there be Limits of the Creation,
whether or no it be not possible that an Intelligent being shall be removed beyond the limits;
and then whether or no there would not be distance between that Intelligent being and the
limits of the Universe, in the same manner, and as properly, as there is between Intelligent
beings and the parts of the Universe, within its limits; I answer, I cannot tell what the Law
of Nature, or the Constitution of God, would be in this case.
Coroll. There is, therefore, no difficulty in answering such questions as these, What
cause was there why the Universe was placed in such a part of Space? and, Why was the
Universe created at such a Time? for, if there be no Space beyond the Universe, it was im-
possible that it should be created in another place; and if there was no Time before, it was
impossible it should be created at another time.
The idea we have of Space, and what we call by that name, is only Coloured Space, and
is entirely taken out of the mind, if Colour be taken away. And so all that we call Extension,
Motion, and Figure, is gone, if Colour is gone. As to any idea of Space, Extension, Distance,
472
NO.IV. Remarks in Mental Philosophy. The Mind.