Canon XV.
If any bishop, lying under any accusation, shall be judged by all the bishops in the
province, and all shall unanimously deliver the same verdict concerning him, he shall not
be again judged by others, but the unanimous sentence of the bishops of the province shall
stand firm.
116
Notes.
Ancient Epitome of Canon XV.
If all the bishops of a province agree with regard to a bishop already sentenced, a new
trial shall not be granted him.
Van Espen.
By the phrase “by others” must be understood bishops called from a neighbouring
province, of which mention is made in the previous canon, where in the case of an agreement
among the bishops, the synod did not wish to be called in, even if it were demanded by the
condemned bishop. This canon, therefore, is a supplement as it were to the preceding. And
for this reason in the Breviarium and in Cresconius’s Collection of Canons they are placed
under a common title, cap. 144, “Concerning the difference of opinion which happens in
the judgment of bishops, or when a bishop is cut off by all the bishops of his province.”
From these canons it is manifest that at first the causes of bishops were agitated and
decided in provincial synods, and this discipline continued for many centuries, and was
little by little departed from in the VIIIth and IXth centuries.
This canon is found in the Corpus Juris Canonici, Gratian’s Decretum, Pars II., Causa
VI., Quæst. IV., Can. v. Gratian adds a note which Van Espen remarks smacks of his own
date rather than of that of the Synod of Antioch.
Canon XV.
230
Canon XV.