Natalis Alexander412 is indeed of opinion that because Pope Zosimus, in the year 417 or
418, cited the fifth canon of Sardica as Nicene, and a synod held at Constantinople in 382
cited the sixth as Nicene, the synod must evidently have been considered as an appendix to
that of Nicea, and therefore its equal, that is, must have been honoured as ecumenical. But
we have already shown how Zosimus and the bishops of Constantinople had been led into
this confusion from the defects of their manuscript collections of the canons. Athanasius,
Sulpicius Severus, Socrates, and the Emperor Justinian were cited in later times for the
ecumenical character of this synod. Athanasius calls it a μεγάλη σύνοδος; Sulpicius Severus
says it was ex toto orbe convocata; and Socrates relates that “Athanasius and other bishops
had demanded an Ecumenical Synod, and that of Sardica had been then summoned.413 It
436
is clear at the first glance that the two last authorities only prove that the Synod had been
intended to be a general one, and the expression “Great Synod,” used by Athanasius, cannot
be taken as simply identical with ecumenical. While, however, the Emperor Justinian, in
his edict of 346, on the Three Chapters, calls the Synod of Sardica ecumenical, he yet, in the
same edict, as well as in other places, does not reckon it among the General Councils, of
which he counts four. To this must be added, first, that the Emperor is not the authority
entitled to decide as to the character of an Ecumenical Synod; and secondly, that the expres-
sion Universale Concilium was employed in a wider sense in speaking of those synods which,
without being general, represented a whole patriarchate.
The Trullan Synod and Pope Nicholas I. are further appealed to. The former in its
second canon approved of the Sardican canons, and Pope Nicholas said of them: “omnis
Ecclesia recepit eos.” But this in no way contains a declaration that the Synod of Sardica was
ecumenical, for the canons of many other councils also—for instance, Ancyra, Neocæsarea,
and others—were generally received without those synods themselves being therefore es-
teemed ecumenical. Nay, the Trullan Synod itself speaks for us; for had it held the Synod
of Sardica to be the second General Council, it would have placed its canons immediately
after those of Nice, whereas they are placed after the four ancient General Councils, and
from this we see that the Trullan Synod did not reckon the Sardican among those councils,
but after them. To this it must be added that the highest Church authorities speak most
decidedly against the synod being ecumenical. We may appeal first to Augustine, who only
knew of the Eusebian assembly at Sardica, and nothing at all of an orthodox synod in that
place; which would have been clearly impossible, if it had at that time been counted among
the ecumenical synods. Pope Gregory the Great414 and St. Isidore of Seville415 speak still
412 Nat. Alex. H. E., sec. iv., Diss. xxvij., Art. 3.
413 Socrates. H. E., Lib. ii., cap. 20.
414 Greg. M. Lib. ii., Epist. 10.
415 Isidor. Hispal. Etymolog., Lib. vi., cap. 16.
801
Excursus as to Whether the Sardican Council Was Ecumenical.