AGAINST VIG1LANTIUS.
421
slept or rather been buried for a long time,
but has been now awakened by Dormitan-
tius. I am surprised you do not tell us that
there must upon no account be martyrdoms,
inasmuch as God, who does not ask for
the blood of goats and bulls, much less re-
quires the blood of men. This is what you
say, or rather, even if you do not say it,
you are taken as meaning to assert it. For
in maintaining that the relics of the martyrs
are to be trodden under foot, you forbid the
shedding of their blood as being worthy of no honour.
9. Respecting vigils and the frequent keep-
ing of night-watches in the basilicas of the
martyrs, I have given a brief reply in another
letter ' which, about two years ago, I wrote to the reverend presbyter Riparius. You argue
that they ought to be abjured, lest we seem to
be often keeping Easter, and appear not to
observe the customary yearly vigils. If so, then sacrifices should not be offered to Christ
on the Lord's day lest we frequently keep the
Easter of our Lord's Resurrection, and intro- duce the custom of having many Easters
instead of one. We must not, however-,
impute to pious men the faults and errors of
youths and worthless women such as are often
detected at night. It is true that, even at the
Easter vigils, something of the kind usually
comes to light ; but the faults of a few form
no argument against religion in general, and
such persons, without keeping vigil, can go
wrong either in their own houses or in those
of other people. The treachery of Judas did
not annul the loyalty of the Apostles. And
if others keep vigil badly, our vigils are not
thereby to be stopped ; nay, rather let those
who sleep to gratify their lust be compelled to
watch that they may preserve their chastity.
For if a thing once done be good, it cannot
be bad if often done ; and if there is some
fault to be avoided, the blame lies not in its
being done often, but in its being done at all.
And so we should not watch at Easter-tide,
for fear that adulterers may satisfy their long
pent-up desires, or that the wife may find an
opportunity /or sinning without having the
key turned against her by her husband. The occasions which seldom recur are those which
are most eagerly longed for.
i o. I cannot traverse all the topics embraced
in the letters of the reverend presbyters ; I
will adduce a few points from the tracts of
Vigilantius. He argues against the signs
and miracles which are wrought in the basilicas
of the martyrs, and says that they are of
service to the unbelieving, not to believers, as
though the question now were for whose
1 Letter CIX.
advantage they occur, not by what power.
Granted that signs belong to the faithless,
who, because they would not obey the word
and doctrine, are brought to believe by means
of signs. Even our Lord wrought signs for
the unbelieving, and yet our Lord's signs are not on that account to be impugned, because
those people were faithless, but must be
worthy of greater admiration because they
were so powerful that they subdued even the
hardest hearts, and compelled men to believe.
And so I will not have you tell me that signs
are for the unbelieving ; but answer my ques-
tion— how is it that poor worthless dust and ashes are associated with this wondrous power
of signs and miracles ? I see, I see, most
unfortunate of mortals, why you are so sad
and what causes your fear. That unclean
spirit who forces you to write these things
has often been tortured by this worthless dust,
aye, and is being tortured at this moment, and
though in your case he conceals his wounds, in others he makes confession. You will
hardly follow the heathen and impious Por-
phyry and Eunomius, and pretend that these
are the tricks of the demons, and that they do
not really cry out, but feign their torments.
Let me give you my advice : go to the basil- icas of the martyrs, and some day you will be
cleansed ; you will find there many in like
case with yourself, and will be set on fire, not
by the martyrs' tapers which offend you, but by invisible flames ; and you will then confess
what you now deny, and will freely proclaim
your name — that you who speak in the person of Vigilantius are really either Mercury, for
greedy of gain was he ; or Nocturnus, who,
according to Plautus's ''Amphitryon," slept while Jupiter, two nights together, had his
adulterous connection with Alcmena, and
thus begat the mighty Hercules ; or at all
events Father Bacchus, of drunken fame,
with the tankard hanging from his shoulder,
with his ever ruby face, foaming lips, and
unbridled brawling.
1 1. Once, when a sudden earthquake in this
province in the middle of the night awoke us
all out of our sleep, you, the most prudent
and the wisest of men, began to pray without
putting your clothes on, and recalled to our
minds the story of Adam and Eve in Paradise ;
they, indeed, when their eyes were opened
were ashamed, for they saw that they were
naked, and covered their shame with the
leaves of trees ; but you, who were stripped
alike of your shirt and of your faith, in the
sudden terror which overwhelmed you, and
with the fumes of your last night's booze still hanging about you, showed your wisdom by
exposing your nakedness in only too evident
a manner to the eyes of the brethren. Such