Chapter II.
A passage quoted by the heretics against repentance is explained in two ways, the first
being that Heb. vi. 4 refers to the impossibility of being baptized again; the second, that what
is impossible with man is possible with God.
6. Being then refuted by the clear example of the Apostle and by his writings, the heretics
yet endeavour to resist further, and say that their opinion is supported by apostolic authority,
bringing forward the passage in the Epistle to the Hebrews: “For it is impossible that those
who were once enlightened, and have tasted the heavenly gift, and have been made partakers
of the Holy Spirit, and have tasted the good word of God, and the powers of the world to
come, should if they fall away be again renewed unto repentance, crucifying again the Son
of God, and put Him to open shame.”2277
7. Could Paul teach in opposition to his own act? He had at Corinth forgiven sin through
penance, how could he himself speak against his own decision? Since, then, he could not
destroy what he had built, we must assume that what he says was different from, but not
contrary to, what had gone before. For what is contrary is opposed to itself, what is different
has ordinarily another meaning. Things which are contrary are not such that one can support
the other. Inasmuch, then, as the Apostle spoke of remitting penance, he could not be silent
as to those who thought that baptism was to be repeated. And it was right first of all to remove
346
our anxiety, and to let us know that even after baptism, if any sinned their sins could be
forgiven them, lest a false belief in a reiterated baptism should lead astray those who were
destitute of all hope of forgiveness. And secondly, it was right to set forth in a well-reasoned
argument that baptism is not to be repeated.
8. And that the writer was speaking of baptism is evident from the very words in which
it is stated that it is impossible to renew unto repentance those who were fallen, inasmuch
as we are renewed by means of the laver of baptism, whereby we are born again, as Paul says
himself: “For we are buried with Him through baptism into death, that, like as Christ rose
from the dead through the glory of the Father, so we, too, should walk in newness of life.”2278
And in another place: “Be ye renewed in the spirit of your mind, and put on the new man
which is created after God.”2279 And elsewhere again: “Thy youth shall be renewed like the
eagle,”2280 because the eagle after death is born again from its ashes, as we being dead in
2277 Heb. vi. 4–6. The use made by the Montanists and Novatians of this passage in support of their heresy
seems to have been one of the reasons why the Epistle to the Hebrews was so late in being received as canonical.
This is stated by one authority in so many words: “Epistola ad Hebræos non legitur propter Novatianos.”
Philastrius, de Hær. 41.
2278 Rom. vi. 4.
2279 Eph. iv. 23.
2280 Ps. civ. [ciii.] 5.
Chapter II. A passage quoted by the heretics against repentance is explained in two ways, the first being that Heb. vi. 4 refers to the impossibility of being baptized again; the second, that what is impossible with man is possible with God.
761
Chapter II. A passage quoted by the heretics against repentance is explained…