that no one afterwards has any courage to assail it; and his companions in arms find the
cxcii
great work of defending the positions, which he has occupied, already done to their hands.
This impossibility of answering his arguments, arises, in the first place, from the strength
and conclusiveness of his reasoning. By first fixing in his own mind, and then exactly defining,
the meaning of his terms, by stating his propositions with logical precision, and by clearly
discerning and stating the connexion between his premises and conclusions, he has given
to metaphysical reasoning very much of the exactness and certainty of mathematical
demonstration.
Another cause of the unanswerable character of his reasonings, is, that he usually follows
several distinct trains of argument, which all terminate in the same conclusion. Each of
them is satisfactory; but the union of all, commencing at different points, and arriving at
the same identical result, cannot fail to convince the mind, that that result is not to he shaken.
A third cause of this is, that he himself anticipates, and effectually answers, not only all
the objections that have been made, but all that apparently can be made, to the points for
which he contends. These he places in the strongest light and examines under every shape
which they can assume in the hands of an evasive antagonist, and shows that, in every possible
form, they are wholly inconclusive.
A fourth cause is his method of treating the opinions of his opponents. It is the identical
method of Euclid. Assuming them as premises, he with great ingenuity shows, that they lead
to palpable absurdity. He demonstrates that his opponents are inconsistent with themselves,
as well as with truth and common sense;—and rarely stops, until he has exposed their error
to contempt and ridicule.
This unanswerableness of Mr. Edwards’s reasonings, in his controversial works, has
been most publicly confessed. The Essay on the Will treats of subjects the most contested
within the limits of theology; and, unless it can be answered, prostrates in the dust the scheme
of doctrines, for which his antagonists so earnestly contend. Yet, hitherto, it stands unmoved
and unassailed; and the waves of controversy break harmless at its base. 90 The treatise on
Original Sin, though written chiefly to overthrow the hypothesis of an individual, is perhaps
not less conclusive in its reasonings. That he succeeded in that design, as well as in establish-
ing the great principles for which he contends will not be doubted by any one who examines
the controversy; and is said to have been virtually confessed, in a melancholy manner, by
Taylor himself. He had indiscreetly boasted, in his larger work, that it never would be
answered. The answer was so complete, that it admitted of no reply. His consequent morti-
fication is said to have shortened his days. Whether it was true, or not, that the grasp of his
antagonist was literally death, it was at least death to the controversy. The treatise on the
90 Dugald Stewart, alluding to it in conversation, is said, on good authority, to have spoken of it thus:—“Ed-
wards on the Will, a work which never was answered, and which never will be answered.”
405
CHAPTER XXV. Concluding remarks