OBJECT. X.
The natural consequence of the doctrine which has been maintained, is the bringing
multitudes of persons of a tender conscience and true piety into great perplexities; who being
at a loss about the state of their souls, must needs be as much in suspense about their duty:
and it is not reasonable to suppose, that God would order things so in the revelations of his
will, as to bring his own people into such perplexities.
Answ. 1. It is for want of the like tenderness of conscience which the godly have, that
the other doctrine which insists on moral sincerity, does not naturally bring those who are
received to communion on those principles, into the same perplexities, through their
doubting of their moral sincerity, of their believing mysteries with all their heart, &c. as has
been already observed. And being free from perplexity, only through stupidity and hardness
of heart, is worse than being in the greatest perplexity through tenderness of conscience.
Answ. 2. Supposing the doctrine which I have maintained, be indeed the doctrine of
God’s word, yet it will not follow, that the perplexities true saints are in through doubting
of their state, are effects owing to the revelations of God’s word. Perplexity and distress of
mind, not only on occasion of the Lord’s supper, but innumerable other occasions, is the
natural and unavoidable consequence of true Christians doubting of their state. But shall
we therefore say, that all these perplexities are owing to the word of God? No, it is not owing
to God, nor to any of his revelations, that true saints ever doubt of their state; his revelations
are plain and clear, and his rules sufficient for men to determine their own condition by.
But, for the most part, it is owing to their own sloth, and giving way to their sinful disposi-
tions. Must God’s institutions and revelations be answerable for all the perplexities men
bring on themselves, through their own negligence and unwatchfulness? It is wisely ordered
that the saints should escape perplexity in no other way than that of great strictness, diligence,
and maintaining the lively, laborious, and self-denying exercises of religion.
It might as well be said, it is unreasonable to suppose that God should order things so
as to bring his own people into such perplexities, as doubting saints are wont to be exercised
with, in the sensible approaches of death; when their doubts tend to vastly greater perplexity,
than in their approaches to the Lord’s table. If Christians would more thoroughly exercise
themselves unto godliness, labouring always to keep a conscience void of offence both towards
God and towards man, it would be the way to have the comfort and taste the sweetness of
religion. If they would so run, not as uncertainly; so fight, not as they that beat the air; it
would be the way for them to escape perplexity, both in ordinances and providences, and
to rejoice and enjoy God in both.—Not but that doubting of their state sometimes arises
from other causes, besides want of watchfulness; it may arise from melancholy, and some
other peculiar disadvantages. But however, it is not owing to God’s revelations nor institu-
tions; which, whatsoever we may suppose them to be, will not prevent the perplexities of
such persons.
OBJ. X. Perplexity occasioned.
1854
OBJ. X. Perplexity occasioned.