SECT. XIV.
The conclusion.
Whether the things which have been alleged, are liable to any tolerable answer in the
way of calm, intelligible, and strict reasoning, 1 must leave others to judge: but I am sensible
they are liable to one sort of answer. It is not unlikely, that some, who value themselves on
the supposed rational and generous principles of the modern fashionable divinity, will have
their indignation and disdain raised at the sight of this discourse, and on perceiving what
things are pretended to be proved in it. And if they think it worthy of being read, or of so
much notice as to say much about it, they may probably renew the usual exclamations, with
additional vehemence and contempt, about the fate of the heathen, Hobbes’s Necessity, and
making men mere machines; accumulating the terrible epithets of fatal, unfrustrable, inev-
itable, irresistible, &c. and it may be, with addition of horrid and blasphemous; and perhaps
much skill may be used to set forth things, which have been said, in colours which shall be
87
shocking to the imaginations, and moving to the passions of those, who have either too
little capacity, or too much confidence of the opinions they have imbibed, and contempt of
the contrary, to try the matter by any serious and circumspect examination. 160 Or difficulties
may be stated and insisted on, which do not belong to the controversy; because, let them
be more or less real, and hard to be resolved, they are not what are owing to any thing dis-
tinguishing of this scheme from that of the Arminians, and would not be removed nor di-
minished by renouncing the former, and adhering to the latter. Or some particular things
may be picked out, which they may think will sound harshest in the ears of the generality;
and these may be glossed and descanted on, with tart and contemptuous words; and from
thence, the whole discourse may be treated with triumph and insult.
It is easy to see, how the decision of most of the points in controversy between Calvinists
and Arminians, depends on the determination of this grand article concerning the Freedom
of the Will requisite to moral agency; and that by clearing and establishing the Calvinistic
doctrine in this point, the chief arguments are obviated by which Arminian doctrines in
160 A writer of the present age, whom I have several times had occasion to mention, speaks once and again
of those who hold the doctrine of Necessity, as scarcely worthy of the name of philosophers. I do not know,
whether he has respect to any particular notion of necessity, that some may have maintained; and, if so, what
doctrine of necessity it is that he means. Whether I am worthy of the name of a philosopher, or not, would be
a question little to the present purpose. If any, and ever so many, should deny it. I should not think it worth the
while to enter into a dispute on that question: Though at the same time I might expect some better answer should
be given to the arguments brought for the truth of the doctrine I maintain; and I might further reasonably desire,
that it might be considered, whether it does not become those, who are truly worthy of the name of philosophers,
to be sensible, that there is a difference between argument and contempt, yea, and a difference between the
contemptibleness of the person that argues, and the inconclusiveness of the arguments he offers.
SECTION XIV. The Conclusion.
760
SECTION XIV. The Conclusion.