omius shall testify for us by his own words, saying as he does that the ungenerate Light is
unapproachable, and has not the power of stooping to experience affections, but affirming
that such a condition is germane and akin to the generate: so that man need feel no gratitude
to the Only-begotten God for what He suffered, if, as they say, it was by the spontaneous
action of His nature that He slipped down to the experience of affections, His essence, which
was capable of being thus affected, being naturally dragged down thereto, which demands
no thanks. For who would welcome as a boon that which takes place by necessity, even if it
be gainful and profitable? For we neither thank fire for its warmth nor water for its fluidity,
as we refer these qualities to the necessity of their several natures, because fire cannot be
deserted by its power of warming, nor can water remain stationary upon an incline, inasmuch
as the slope spontaneously draws its motion onwards. If, then, they say that the benefit
wrought by the Son through His incarnation was by a necessity of His nature, they certainly
render Him no thanks, inasmuch as they refer what He did, not to an authoritative power,
but to a natural compulsion. But if, while they experience the benefit of the gift, they disparage
the lovingkindness that brought it, I fear lest their impiety should work round to the opposite
error, and lest they should deem the condition of the Son, that could be thus affected, worthy
of more honour than the freedom from such affections possessed by the Father, making
their own advantage the criterion of good. For if the case had been that the Son was incapable
of being thus affected, as they affirm of the Father, our nature would still have remained in
its miserable plight, inasmuch as there would have been none to lift up man’s nature to in-
corruption by what He Himself experienced;—and so it escapes notice that the cunning of
these quibblers, by the very means which it employs in its attempt to destroy the majesty of
the Only-begotten God, does but raise men’s conceptions of Him to a grander and loftier
height, seeing it is the case that He Who has the power to act, is more to be honoured than
one who is powerless for good.
471
He then again charges Eunomius with having learnt his term from…