THE DIALOGUE AGAINST THE LUCIFERIANS.
321
O. Since you put the whole thing in a nut-
shell and obstinately cling to your position,
that the case of the bishop is different from
that of the layman, I will do what you wish,
and I shall not be sorry to avail myself of the
opportunity you offer and come to close
quarters. Explain why you receive a layman
coming from the Arians, but do not receive a
bishop.
L. I receive a layman who confesses that
he has erred ; and the Lord willeth not the
death of a sinner, but rather that he should
repent.
O. Receive then also a bishop who, as well
as the layman, confesses that he has erred,
and it still holds good that the Lord willeth
not the death of a sinner, but rather that he
should repent.
L. If he confesses his error why does he
continue a bishop ? Let him lay aside his
1 episcopal functions, and I grant pardon to the penitent.
O. I will answer you in your own words. If
a layman confesses his error, how is it he con-
tinues a layman ? Let him lay aside his lay-
priesthood, that is, his baptism, and I grant
pardon to the penitent. For it is written
* " He made us to be a kingdom, to be priests
unto his God and Father." And again, s " A
holy nation, a royal priesthood, an elect race." Everything which is forbidden to a Christian,
is forbidden to both bishop and layman. He
who does penance condemns his former life.
If a penitent bishop may not continue what he
was, neither may a penitent layman remain in
that state on account of which he confesses
himself a penitent.
L. We receive the laity, because no one will
be induced to change, if he knows he must be
baptized again. And then, if they are reject-
ed, we become the cause of their destruction.
O. By receiving a layman you save a single
soul : and I in receiving a bishop unite to the
Church, I will not say the people of one city,
but the whole 4 province of which he is the head ; if I drive him away, he will drag down
many with him to ruin. Wherefore I beseech
you to apply the same reason which you think
you have for receiving the few to the salva-
tion of the whole world. But if you are not
satisfied with this, if you are so hard, or rather
so unreasonably unmerciful as to think him who
gave baptism an enemy of Christ, though you
account him who received it a son, we do not
so contradict ourselves: we either receive a
bishop as well as the people which is con-
stituted as a Christian people by him, or if we
1 Sacerdotium. » Apoc. i. 6. ' i Pet. ii. 9.
4 Thit is diocese. The word diocese was in early times the larger expression, and contained many provinces. See Can-
on II of Constantinople, Bright's edition, and note. 21
do not receive a bishop, we know that we must
also reject his people.
5. L. Pray, have you not read what is said
concerning the bishops, J " Ye are the salt of the earth : but if the salt have lost its savour,
wherewith shall it be salted ? It is thence-
forth good for nothing, but to be cast out and
trodden under foot of man." And then there
is the fact that the priest * intercedes with God for the sinful people, while there is no one to
entreat for the priest. Now these two pas-
sages of Scripture tend to the same conclu-
sion. For as salt seasons all food and nothing
is so pleasant as to please the palate without
it : so the bishop is the seasoning of the whole
world and of his own Church, and if he lose his
savour through the denial of truth, or through
heresy, or lust, or, to comprehend all in one
word, through sin of any kind, by what other
can he be seasoned, when he was the season-
ing of all ? The priest, we know, offers his
oblation for the layman, lays his hand upon
him when submissive, invokes the return of
the Holy Spirit, and thus, after inviting the
prayers of the people, reconciles to the altar him who had been delivered to Satan for the
destruction of the flesh that the spirit might
be saved ; nor does he restore one member to
health until all the members have wept to-
gether with him. For a father easily pardons
his son, when the mother entreats for her off-
spring. If then it is by the priestly order that
a penitent layman is restored to the Church,
and pardon follows where sorrow has gone
before, it is clear that a priest who has been removed from his order cannot be restored to
the place he has forfeited, because either he
will be a penitent and then he cannot be a
priest, or if he continues to hold office he cannot
be brought back to the Church by penitential
discipline. Will you dare to spoil the savour of the Church with the salt which has lost its
savour ? Will you replace at the altar the
man who having been cast out ought to
lie in the mire and be trodden under foot
by all men ? What then will become of the
Apostle's command, ""The bishop must be
blameless as God's steward " ? And again,
4 " But let a man prove himself, and so let him
come." What becomes of our Lord's intima-
tion, 6 " Neither cast your pearls before the
swine " ? But if you understand the words as a general admonition, how much more must
care be exercised in the case of priests when
so much precaution is taken where the laity
are concerned ? °" Depart, I pray you," says
the Lord by Moses, " from the tents of these wicked men, and touch nothing of theirs,
lest ye be consumed in all their sins." And 1 Matt. v. 13.
* i Cor. xi. 28.
5 Lev. ix. 7.
5 Matt. vii. 6.
» Tit. i. 7.
* Numb. xvi. 26.