him, give up themselves and all to him.” And again, (p. 106. e. 107. a) “Man since the fall
has a natural unlikeness to God, and hates the holiness and purity of the divine nature.”
And in his sermon on Isa. xlv. 11. he says to his hearers, If your nature remain unrenewed
and unsanctified,—you are the enemies of God and Christ by wicked works, and an impure
heart.—But yet now it seems, some of these may profess real friendship to Christ, and loving
him above the world, and speak true.
And these things are no less inconsistent with what Mr. W. says in the very book under
consideration. He here says, (p. 36.) “Why should any divine now tell us, that these same
professions do not imply that there are any pretences of any real friendship, that they import
no pretence of loving God more, yea, not so much, as his enemies, no pretence to love God
above the world?” When he himself is the divine that tells us so, or plainly supposes so in
this very book of his. For, in p. 8, 9. having mentioned the profession communicants may
be required to make, he then says, that such a profession contains all that is essential to true
religion in it; and if this is the fruit of the love of God, it is true godliness: plainly supposing,
500
that persons may have these things without the love of God; as the reader will see more
evidently if he views the place. So that the profession must imply real friendship, and love
to God, even above the world; and yet must contain only such things as may be with or
without the love of God indiscriminately.
Mr. W. allows, that in order to come to sacraments men ought to profess a subjection
to Christ with all their hearts, (p. 10. d.) and to be devoted to the service of God, (p. 49. d.)
and to give up themselves to Christ, to be taught, ruled, and led by him in a gospel-way to
salvation, (p. 31. e. and p. 32. a.) And though he and Mr. Stoddard taught, that it is lawful
for some unsanctified men to come to sacraments, yet Mr. W. supposes it to be unlawful
for any to come to sacraments serving two masters; and says Mr. S. taught that they ought
to covenant with God with their whole hearts, and give up all their hearts and lives to Christ.
We are therefore to understand Mr. W. that some unsanctified men can profess all these
things, and speak true. Strange doctrine for a christian divine! Let us see whether Mr. S.
taught such doctrine. He taught that faith in Christ is the first act of obedience that any
sinner does perform; that it is by faith that a man first gives himself to be God’s servant.
(Safety of App. p. 228. e. p. 229. a.) That all those who are not converted, are under the
dominion of sin, enemies to God. (Ibid. p. 5. c. d.) That there is no obedience to God in
what they do, who have only common grace; that they do not attend the will of God. (Ibid.
p. 7. d.) That all ungodly men are servants of Satan, and live in a way of rebellion against
God. ( Ibid. p. 94. b.) That they are enemies to the authority of God; to the wisdom, power,
and justice of God, yea to the very being of God; they have a preparedness of heart to all
wickedness that is committed in the world, if God did not restrain them; that if they were
in the circumstances that the fallen angels are in they would be as the very devils. (Ibid. p.
95.) That their hearts are like the hearts of devils, as full of sin as a toad is full of poison,
1938
SECTION V. Mr. W. inconsistent with Mr. Stoddard.