Testimonia

Publiek archief van verzamelde en verwerkte bronrecords.
Overzicht / Records / record

source-document-page-text

Technische verwerking bevestigt geen inhoudelijke beoordeling of toestemming voor openbare publicatie.

record_key: c9929cc5c191044968080b47a753b0f613bcc51461991ac1ef78619b05e78866
origineel ID: pdf:7465aab8a431a0646ab28783656dddce01c11785ad4eff6945e197a8e05891d2:page:28 · verwerkingsstatus: Verwerkt, inhoudelijk nog niet beoordeeld · teksthash: 9fe7c5e9f4782502fb5df496ac9e008a15a8da99108d16a581dd589c58bea907 · 7,780 tekens

Tekst tekstblob openen

PROLEGOMENA. authority of the Bishop of Rome supreme in the West.' It would be useful to maintainers of tlie Koman supremacy if they could adduce instances of any assertion or acceptance of similar authority in the East. So it has been said that Theodoret appealed to the Pope.' In a sense this is of course perfectly true. Theodoret did appeal to the Pope. But tlie whole superstructure of pap:d supremacy, so far as Theodoret is concerned, is really based upon a poor paronomasia. The bishop of Cyrus " appealed " to the bishop of Rome as any bisiiop believing himself to lie under an unjust sentence might appeal to any other bishop, and as Theodoret did appeal to other bishops. It is quite true that the church of Rome had many claims to honour and regard, as Theodoret himself felicitously and opportunely points out, and that the present occupant of its throne was a man of unblemished orthodoxy and of commanding personal dignity. But to recognise these facts is a long way from ad- mitting that this very dignified see had either dc facto or de jure any coercive jurisdiction over the Metropolitans of Alexandria or of Hierapolis, to the latter of whom Cyrus was subordinate. Theodoret himself quotes the crucial passage in St. Matthew's gospeP ap- parently without any idea that the "Petra" means all the successors of the " Petrus." ■* What Theodoret asked from Leo was not the sentence of a superior but the sympathy and support of an influential brother. What made it so peculiarly important that he should gain the ear and the .ipproval of Leo was that Rome had been wholly unconcerned in the intrigue which condemned him. He could have had no more idea of papal authority in the later ultramontane sense than he could of the decrees of the Vatican Council. Bound as he was to do his utmost to vindicate not so much his own position and doctrinal soundness, as the truth now trampled on by the combined factions of Alexandria and the court, he naturally turned to Leo as alike the most respected and most independent bishop of his age.* Leo, however, could do little or nothing to help him. Theodosius, completely under the intluencc of Chrysaphius luul Dioscorus, was quite satisfied as to the proper constitution and equity of the Latrociniuni. V. — Theodoret and Cpialcedox. Xow, not for the last time in history, an important part was played by a horse. In July, 450, Theodosius, while hunting in the neighbourhood of his capital, was thrown from the saddle into a stream, hurt his spine, and a few days afterwards died.° With him died the cause of Eutyches and of Chrysaphius. The eunuch was promptly executed, and at last a Council was conceded to reconsider and rectify the crimes and blimders of the Latrociniuni.' But the Empress and her venerable husband did not wait for the Council to undo some of the wrong done to Theodoret, and the large place he filled in the eyes and estimation of the oriental world is shewn by the interest shewn at Constantinople in his behalf." The decree of relegation appears to have been rescinded, and he was free to present himself at the synod. On the first assembling of the five hundred bishops,' under the ^ Cf. Milmnn Lat. Christ. Book ii. Chap, iv ; Const. V.llcntin. iii Aujj. npud S. Leon. op. epist. xi. 2Garnerius, Ihc Jesuit, in his dissertation on tlie lii'e ot'Tiicodorct writes : *' When Theodoret got news of his deposition he deterniinedto send envoys to the apostolic see, that is to the head of all the churches in the world, to plead his cause before the righteous judgment seat of St. Leo," and in his summary of his own chapter he says ** Theodoret appeals to the apostolic see," 3 Matt. xvi. iS. < Ep. CXLVI. Ocf. Glubokowski. ])p. 337, 239. Du Pin. iv. S.v Cardinal Newman, in hi-^ very bright and symp.alhetic sketch of Tlieodoret, (Hist. Sketches ii. _^oS cd. 1S91) writes the following remarkable sentence. "This, at least, he has in common with St. Chrysostom that both of them were deprived of their episcopal rank by a council, both appealed to the holy see, and by the holy see both were cleared and restored to their ecclesiastical dignities." It would be dUhcult in the compass of so short a sentence to combine more statements so completely misleading. To say that Chrysostom and Theodoret both ap- pealed to the " holy see" is as much an anachronism as to say that they appealed to the Court of the Vatican or to the Dome of St. Peter's. In their day there was no holy see, that is to say, /car* tfovfic. Ail sees were holy sees, just as all bishops were styled your holiness. Rome, it is true, was the only apostolical see in the West, but it was not the only apostolical see, and whatever official precedence it could claim over Antioch, Jerusalem, and Alexandria, was due to ils being the see of the old imperial capital, u precedence expressly ordered at Chalcedon to be shared witll the new Rome on the Bosphorus. As to the ** appeal," we have seen what it meant in the case of Theodoret. It meant the same in the case of Chrysostom. Cut to the quick at the cruel and brutal treatment of his friends after his banishment from Constantinople in the summer of 404 he pleaded his cause in letters sent as well to Venerius of Milan and Chromatins of Aquileia as to Innocent of Rome. Innocent very properly espoused his cause, declared his deposition void, and did his best to move Honorius to move Arcadius to con- voke acouncil. The cruel story of the lona: martyrdom of bitter exile and the death in the lonely chapel at Comana is a terri- ble satire on the restoration to ecclesiastical dii^nities. The unwary reader of** the historical sketch" might imagine the famous John of the mouth of gold brought back in triumph to Constantinople by the authority of tlie pope in 404 as he had been by the enthusiasm of his flock in 403, and Arcadius and Eudoxia cowering: before the power of Holy Church like Henry IV. at Canosea in 1077. The true picture of the three years of agony which preceded the old man's passage to the better world in 407 is a painful contrast to contemplate (Palhid. Dial. 1-3. Theodoret V. 34. Sozomen viii. 26, 27, 3S.) Of Theodoret's restoration to " ecclesiastical dignity," and Leo's part in it, we shall see further on. »cf. the deaths of William I. and William HI. of England. 'Thous^h Marcian's independence of western dictation was shewn in the summoning of the bishops not to a place in Italy, as I>eo had hoped and urged, but to Chalcedon, the beautiful Asiatic suburb of Constantinople. ' Epp. CXXXIX, CXL. * Accounts of the numbers vary. Marcellinus says 630, There were more than 400 signatures.

Versies (1)

Versie f3ce135ffcdd28de37fbfbeec150ccfe96edf78444499f59d096cb424f31c0d3
{"cropbox":["0","0","502.1","714.2"],"footnote_boundaries_verified":false,"mediabox":["0","0","502.08","714.24"],"native_document_header_ref":{"header_context_sha256":"e9e5dc59092135e28d2c04a2f11a94e5cfd05dff5c18b877fb567f7609cbc949","source_sha256":"7465aab8a431a0646ab28783656dddce01c11785ad4eff6945e197a8e05891d2"},"native_page":{"object_generation":0,"object_number":65,"page_index_zero_based":28},"reading_order":"pypdf-plain-extraction-with-native-visitor-matrices","record_kind":"derived-native-PDF-page-text","rotation":0,"semantic_admission":false,"source_sha256":"7465aab8a431a0646ab28783656dddce01c11785ad4eff6945e197a8e05891d2","text_layer_empty":false,"text_layer_error":null}

references: [] | work_id: | origin: derived-PDF-page-text-unreviewed | source:

Plaatsingen (1)

OrdinalInputVersie
page:2845927f3ce135ffcdd28de37fbfbeec150ccfe96edf78444499f59d096cb424f31c0d3

Bijbelverwijzingen (0)

CoördinaatReferentie

Live-status (0)

Live IDStatusMatchesSchema