§5. Then, again discussing the true Light and unapproachable Light of the Father and of
the Son, special attributes, community and essence, and showing the relation of “generate”
and “ungenerate,” as involving no opposition in sense1060, but presenting an opposition and
contradiction admitting of no middle term, he ends the book.
But I feel that my argument is running away with me, for it does not remain in the
regular course, but, like some hot-blooded and spirited colt, is carried away by the blas-
phemies of our opponents to range over the absurdities of their system. Accordingly we
must restrain it when it would run wild beyond the bounds of moderation in demonstration
of absurd consequences. But the kindly reader will doubtless pardon what we have said, not
imputing the absurdity that emerges from our investigation to us, but to those who laid
down such mischievous premises. We must, however, now transfer our attention to another
247
of his statements. For he says that our God also is composite, in that while we suppose the
Light to be common, we yet separate the one Light from the other by certain special attributes
and various differences. For that is none the less composite which, while united by one
common nature, is yet separated by certain differences and conjunctions of peculiarities1061.
To this our answer is short and easily dismissed. For what he brings as matter of accusation
against our doctrines we acknowledge against ourselves, if he is not found to establish the
same position by his own words. Let us just consider what he has written. He calls the Lord
“true” Light, and the Father Light “unapproachable.” Accordingly, by thus naming each, he
also acknowledges their community in respect to light. But as titles are applied to things
because they fit them, as he has often insisted, we do not conceive that the name of “light”
is used of the Divine Nature barely, apart from some meaning, but rather that it is predicated
by virtue of some underlying reality. Accordingly, by the use of a common name, they re-
cognize the identity of the objects signified, since they have already declared that the natures
of those things which have the same name cannot be different. Since, then, the meaning of
“Light” is one and the same, the addition of “unapproachable” and “true,” according to the
language of heresy, separates the common nature by specific differences, so that the Light
of the Father is conceived as one thing, and the Light of the Son as another, separated one
from the other by special properties. Let him, then, either overthrow his own positions to
avoid making out by his statements that the Deity is composite, or let him abstain from
charging against us what he may see contained in his own language. For our statement does
not hereby violate the simplicity of the Godhead, since community and specific difference
are not essence, so that the conjunction of these should render the subject composite1062.
1060 The composer of the analysis seems to have been slightly confused by the discussion on the nature of
contradictory opposition.
1061 It is not clear how far the preceding sentences are an exact reproduction of Eunomius: they are probably
a summary of his argument.
1062 Oehler’s punctuation seems rather to obscure the sense.
Then, again discussing the true Light and unapproachable Light of the Father and of the Son, special attributes, community and essence, and showing the relation of “generate” and “ungenerate,” as involving no opposition in sense, but presenting an opposition and contradiction admitting of no middle term, he ends the book.
472
Then, again discussing the true Light and unapproachable Light of the Father…