SECT. IV.
Some particular errors that have risen from several of the preceding causes—Censuring
others.
In some cases perhaps they have chiefly owing to one, and in others to another, and in
others to the influence of several, or all conjunctly. And here the first thing I would take
notice of is, censuring professing Christians of good standing in the visible church, as un-
converted. I need not repeat what I have elsewhere said to show this to be against the plain,
frequent, and strict prohibitions of the word of God. It is the worst disease that has attended
this work, most contrary to the spirit and rules of Christianity, and of the worst con-
sequences.—There is a most unhappy tincture that the minds of many, both ministers and
people, have received that way. The manner of many has been, when they first enter into
conversation with any person that seems to make any pretences to religion, to fix a judgment
of him, from his manner of talking of religious things, whether he be converted, or experi-
mentally acquainted with vital piety, or not; and then to treat him accordingly, and freely
to express their thoughts of him to others, especially those of whom they have a good
opinion, as true Christians, and accepted as brethren and companions in Christ. Or if they
do not declare their minds expressly, yet by their manner of speaking of them, at least to
their friends, they will show plainly what their thoughts are. So, when they have heard any
minister pray or preach, their first work has been to observe him on a design of discerning
him, whether he be a converted man or no; whether he prays like one that feels the saving
power of God’s Spirit in his heart, and whether he preaches like one that knows what he
says. It has been so much the way in some places, that many new converts do not know but
it is their duty to do so, they know no other way. And when once persons yield to such a
notion, and give in to such a humour, they will quickly grow very discerning in their own
apprehension, and think they can easily tell a hypocrite. And when once they have passed
their censure, every thing seems to confirm it; they see more and more in the person they
have censured, that seems to them to show plainly that he is an unconverted man. And then,
if the person censured be a minister, every thing in his public performances seems dead and
sapless, and to do them no good at all, but on the contrary to be of a deadening influence,
and poisonous to the soul; yea, it seems worse and worse to them, his preaching grows more
and more intolerable. Which is owing to a secret, strong prejudice, that steals in more and
more upon the mind, as experience plainly and certainly shows. When the Spirit of God
was wonderfully poured out in this place more than seven years ago, and near thirty souls
in a week, take one with another, for five or six weeks together, were to appearance brought
home to Christ, and all the town seemed to be alive and full of God, there was no such notion
or humour prevailing here. When ministers preached here, as very many did at that time,
young and old, our people did not go about to discern whether they were men of experience
or not; they did not know that they must. Mr. Stoddard never brought them up in that way;
SECTION IV. Of censuring professing Christians.
1696
SECTION IV. Of censuring professing Christians.