Chapter 14.—That Plato, Who Excluded Poets from a Well-Ordered City, Was Better
Than These Gods Who Desire to Be Honoured by Theatrical Plays.
We have still to inquire why the poets who write the plays, and who by the law of the
twelve tables are prohibited from injuring the good name of the citizens, are reckoned more
estimable than the actors, though they so shamefully asperse the character of the gods? Is
it right that the actors of these poetical and God-dishonoring effusions be branded, while
their authors are honored? Must we not here award the palm to a Greek, Plato, who, in
framing his ideal republic,105 conceived that poets should be banished from the city as en-
emies of the state? He could not brook that the gods be brought into disrepute, nor that the
minds of the citizens be depraved and besotted, by the fictions of the poets. Compare now
human nature as you see it in Plato, expelling poets from the city that the citizens be un-
injured, with the divine nature as you see it in these gods exacting plays in their own honor.
Plato strove, though unsuccessfully, to persuade the light-minded and lascivious Greeks to
abstain from so much as writing such plays; the gods used their authority to extort the acting
of the same from the dignified and sober-minded Romans. And not content with having
them acted, they had them dedicated to themselves, consecrated to themselves, solemnly
celebrated in their own honor. To which, then, would it be more becoming in a state to
decree divine honors,—to Plato, who prohibited these wicked and licentious plays, or to
the demons who delighted in blinding men to the truth of what Plato unsuccessfully sought
to inculcate?
This philosopher, Plato, has been elevated by Labeo to the rank of a demigod, and set
thus upon a level with such as Hercules and Romulus. Labeo ranks demigods higher than
heroes, but both he counts among the deities. But I have no doubt that he thinks this man
whom he reckons a demigod worthy of greater respect not only than the heroes, but also
than the gods themselves. The laws of the Romans and the speculations of Plato have this
resemblance, that the latter pronounce a wholesale condemnation of poetical fictions, while
the former restrain the license of satire, at least so far as men are the objects of it. Plato will
not suffer poets even to dwell in his city: the laws of Rome prohibit actors from being enrolled
as citizens; and if they had not feared to offend the gods who had asked the services of the
players, they would in all likelihood have banished them altogether. It is obvious, therefore,
that the Romans could not receive, nor reasonably expect to receive, laws for the regulation
of their conduct from their gods, since the laws they themselves enacted far surpassed and
put to shame the morality of the gods. The gods demand stageplays in their own honor;
the Romans exclude the players from all civic honors;106 the former commanded that they
should be celebrated by the scenic representation of their own disgrace; the latter commanded
105 See the Republic, book iii.
106 Comp. Tertullian, De Spectac. c. 22.
That Plato, Who Excluded Poets from a Well-Ordered City, Was Better Than These Gods Who Desire to Be Honoured by Theatrical Plays.
85
That Plato, Who Excluded Poets from a Well-Ordered City, Was Better Than…