LETTER CXXXIII.
275
corresponds to Jovinian's second position.1 You must, therefore, take the answer which I
have given to him as equally applicable to
yourself. Where men's opinions are the same their destinies can hardly be different.
4. Such being the state of the case, what
object is served by "silly women laden with sins, carried about with every wind of doc-
trine, ever learning and never able to come
to the knowledge of the truth ? "a Or how is the cause helped by the men who dance
attendance upon these, men with itching ears " who know neither how to hear nor how to
speak ? They confound old mire with new
cement and, as Ezekiel says, daub a wall with
untempered mortar ; so that, when the truth
comes in a shower, they are brought to
nought.* It was with the help of the harlot
Helena that Simon Magus founded his sect.6 Bands of women accompanied Nicolas of
Antioch that deviser of all uncleanness.' Marcion sent a woman before him to Rome
to prepare men's minds to fall into his snares.7 Apelles possessed in Philumena an associate
in his false doctrines." Montanus, that mouthpiece of an unclean spirit, used two
rich and high born ladies Prisca and Max-
imilla first to bribe and then to pervert many
churches.* Leaving ancient history I will pass to times nearer to our own. Arius in-
tent on leading the world astray began by
misleading the Emperor's sister.10 The re- sources of Lucilla helped Donatus to defile
with his polluting baptism many unhappy
persons throughout Africa.11 In Spain the blind woman Agape led the blind man Elpi-
dius into the ditch.1* He was followed by Priscillian, an enthusiastic votary of Zoro-
aster and a magian before he became a
bishop. A woman named Galla seconded
his efforts and left a gadabout sister to per-
petuate a second heresy of a kindred form.13
Now also the mystery of iniquity is working.14
I Sec Against Jovinian, book ii. i. His second position is that
"persons baptized with water and the spirit cannot be tempted CM the devil."
* Eph. iv. 14 ; i Tim. iii. 6,7. * a Tim. iv. 3. * Ezek. xiii. 10-16.
* This legendary companion and disciple of Simon Magus is said to have been identified by him with Helen of Troy. Ac-
cording to Justin Martyr she had been a prostitute at Tyre.
* Cf. Epiphanius, Adv. Hacr. lib. i. torn, ii, p. 76, ed. Migne.
7 Jerome is alone in speaking of this emissary. It has been suggested that he may have had in mind the gnostic Marcellina,
who came to Rome during the episcopate of Anicetus.
8 Apelles, the most famous of the disciples of Marcion, lived
and taught mainly at Rome. Philumena was a clairvoyante whose revelations he regarded as inspired.
* See Letter XLI.
10 Constantia, sister of Constantino the Great.
1 ' Lucilla, a wealthy lady of Carthage, having been condemned by its bishop Caecilianus. is said to have procured his deposition
by bribing his fellow-bishops.
17 Agape, a Spanish lady, was a disciple of the gnostic Marcus of Memphis (ct. Letter LXXV. $1). She was thus one of the
links between the gnosticism of the East and the Priscillianism
of Spain. Elpidius was a rhetorician who spread in Spain the Zoroastrian opinions which culminated in Priscillianism.
II Of these sisters nothing further is known. I4aTh. ii. 7.
Men and women in turn lay snares for each
other till we cannot but recall the prophet's
words : " the partridge hath cried aloud, she hath gathered young which she hath not
brought forth, she getteth riches and not by
right ; in the midst of her days she shall leave
them, and at her end she shall be a fool." l 5. The better to deceive men they have
added to the maxim given above2 the saving
clause " but not without the grace of God ; " and this may at the first blush take in some
readers. However, when it is carefully sifted
and considered, it can deceive nobody. For
while they acknowledge the grace of God,
they tell us that our acts* do not depend upon His help. Rather, they understand by the
grace of God free will and the command-
ments of the Law. They quote Isaiah's
words : " God hath given the law to aid
men,"8 and say that we ought to thank Him for having created us such that of our own
free will we can choose the good and avoid
the evil. Nor do they see that in alleging
this the devil uses their lips to hiss out an
intolerable blasphemy. For if God's grace is limited to this that He has formed us with
wills of our own, and if we are to rest con-
tent with free will, not seeking the divine aid
lest this should be impaired, we should cease
to pray ; for we cannot entreat God's mercy to give us daily what is already in our hands
having been given to us once for all. Those
who think thus make prayer impossible and
boast that free will makes them not merely
controllers of themselves but as powerful as
God. For they need no external help. Away
with fasting, away with every form of self-
restraint ! For why need I strive to win by
toil what has once for all been placed within
my reach ? The argument that I am using is
not mine ; it is that put forward by a dis-
ciple of Pelagius, or rather one who is the
teacher and commander of his whole army.4 This man, who is the opposite of Paul for he
is a vessel of perdition, roams through thick-
ets— not, as his partisans say, of syllogisms,
but of solecisms, and theorizes thus : " If I do nothing without the help of God and if
all that I do is His act, I cease to labour and
the crown that I shall win will belong not to
me but to the grace of God. It is idle for
Him to have given me the power of choice
if I cannot use it without His constant help.
For will that requires external support ceases
to be will. God has given me freedom of
1 Jer. xvii. n, Vulg.
2 Viz., *%A man may be without sin." See for this and the other statements of PelaRius, Aug. de Gestis Pelagii, esp. c. 2
and 6. Jerome's Anti-Pelagian Dialogue takes these words as containing the essence of Pclagianism. s Isa. vui. so, I.XX.
4 Celestius is meant, after Pelagius the principal champion of free will.