wanting in such worth! If It is a subject by virtue of its nature, then why is It made the unction
of Kingship, and so associated with the Kingly dignity of the Only-begotten? If, on the other
hand, the capacity to rule is shown by Its being included in the majesty of Kingship, where
is the necessity of having everything dragged down to a plebeian1256 and servile lower con-
dition, and numbered with the subject creation? When we affirm of the Spirit the two con-
ditions, we cannot be in both cases speaking the truth: i.e. that He is ruling, and that He is
subject. If He rules, He is not under any lord, but if He is subject, then He cannot be com-
322
prehended with the Being who is a King. Men are recognized as amongst men, angels
amongst angels, everything amongst its kind; and so the Holy Spirit must needs be believed
to belong to one only of two worlds; to the ruling, or to the inferior world; for between these
two our reason can recognize nothing; no new invention of any natural attribute on the
borderland of the Created and the Uncreated can be thought of, such as would participate
in both, yet be neither entirely; we cannot imagine such an amalgamation and welding to-
gether of opposites by anything being blended of the Created and the Uncreated, and two
opposites thus coalescing into one person, in which case the result of that strange mixture
would not only be a composite thing, but composed of elements that were unlike, and dis-
agreeing as to time; for that which receives its personality from a creation is assuredly pos-
terior to that which subsists without a creation.
If, then, they declare the Holy Ghost to be blended of both, they must consequently
view that blending as of a prior with a posterior thing; and, according to them, He will be
prior to Himself; and reversely, posterior to Himself; from the Uncreated He will get the
seniority, and from the Created the juniority. But, in the nature of things, this cannot be;
and so it must most certainly be true to affirm of the Holy Spirit one only of these alternatives,
and that is, the attribute of being Uncreated; for notice the amount of absurdity involved
in the other alternative; all things that we can think of in the actual creation have, by virtue
of all having received their existence by an act of creation, a rank and value perfectly equal
in all cases, and so what reason can there be for separating the Holy Spirit from the rest of
the creation, and ranking Him with the Father and the Son? Logic, then, will discover this
about Him; That which is contemplated as part of the Uncreated, does not exist by creation;
or, if It does, then It has no more power than its kindred creation, It cannot associate itself
with that Transcendent Nature; if, on the other hand, they declare that He is a created being,
and at the same time has a power which is above the creation, then the creation will be found
at variance with itself, divided into ruler and ruled, so that part of it is the benefactor, part
the benefited, part the sanctifier, part the sanctified; and all that fund of blessings which we
believe to be provided for the creation by the Holy Spirit are present in Him, welling up
1256 ἰδιωτικήν. On 1 Cor. xiv. 16, ῾Ο ἀναπληρῶν τὸν τόπον τοῦ ἰδιώτου, Theodoret says, “ἰδιώτην καλεῖ
τὸν ἐν τῷ λαικῷ τάγματι τεταγμένον.” Theophylact also renders the word by the same equivalent.
599
On the Holy Spirit.